B2-18-246 HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION & CITY OF BROCKTON & MICHAEL McKENNA, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Gregory V. Sullivan, Esq. Malloy & Sullivan 59 Water Street Hingham, MA 02043 Appearance for Human Resources Division: Mark P. Detwiler, Esq. Human Resources Division 100 Cambridge Street: Suite 600 Boston, MA 02114 Appearance for City of Brockton: Karen A. Fisher, Esq.

Ralph appeals from a judgment of the Superior Court affirming the decision of the Civil Service Commission (commission) 1 Human Resources Division. 2 disallowing Sergeant Ralph additional points on a promotional examination for twenty-five years of service under G. L. c. 31, 59, and additional points for previous experience in the position sought under G. L. c. 31, 22.

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEMORANDUM OF DECISION AND ORDER ON PARTIES CROSS MOTIONS FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS In this action, the plaintiff, Thomas Ralph (Ralph), appeals the decision of the Civil Service Commission (CSC) allowing the Human Resources Divisions (HRD) motions to dismiss Ralph's consolidated appeals of HRDs denials of his requests for two additional training and experience points on four civil service promotional examinations. ' Before

G1-18-065 HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION & BOSTON FIRE DEPARTMENT, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Pro Se Abbymael Rodriguez Appearance for Human Resources Division: Patrick Butler, Esq. Human Resources Division One Ashburton Place Boston, MA 02108 Appearance for Boston Fire Department: Jordana Westerman, Esq. City of Boston Office of Labor Relations 1 City Hall Square Boston, MA 02204 Commissioner: Christopher C.

HAMPDEN_COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT FILED _ i ERIK SUNNY PLAINTIFF OCT 0:8 2021 vs. ie CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION CLERK OF COURTS - AND HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION DEFENDANTS . .

E-19-029 HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION & TOWN OF WINTHROP, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Pro Se Giulio Bonavita Appearance for Human Resources Division: Patrick G. Butler, Esq. Human Resources Division 100 Cambridge Street, Suite 600 Boston, MA 02114 Appearance for Town of Winthrop: Howard L. Greenspan, Esq. 200 Broadway, Suite 304 Lynnfield, MA 01940 Commissioner: Christopher C. Bowman ORDER OF DISMISSAL 1.

E-18-188 E-18-195 CITY OF HAVERHILL & HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Stephen C. Pfaff, Esq. Louison, Costello, Condon & Pfaff, LLP 101 Summer Street Boston, MA 02110 Appearance for City of Haverhill: Timothy D. Zessin, Esq. KP Law 101 Arch Street 12th Floor Boston, MA 02110 Appearance for Human Resources Division: Melissa Thomson, Esq.

The human resources division (division) denied the request and McGunigle appealed to the Civil Service Commission (commission), which dismissed his appeal. After review in the Superior Court, a judge granted judgment on the pleadings in favor of the commission and the other defendants. appeals. McGunigle We affirm. Background. We briefly summarize the facts found by the hearing commissioner.

This matter is before the court on plaintiff Joseph McGunigles (McGunigle) motion for judgment on the pleadings arguing that defendant Civil Service Commissions (the t\jyh ^ ^ Commission) erred in its April 1 i, 2019, denial of his appeal of the Human Resource Divisions (HRD) denial of his request for a preferential position on the civil service employment eligibility list for the Quincy Fire Department.