Civil Service Commission

Our collections contain 2,717 items and 2,719 documents where this agency is the custodian.

Newest Requests

Listed below are the newest items we have received from Civil Service Commission. Click here for the complete list.

Bateman, Lawrence v. Town of Winchester 4/17/25

By agreement of the parties, the Commission issued an order resolving a promotional bypass appeal for temporary fire lieutenant by reminding the Town to comply with all civil service law and rules, including written notification of reasons to bypassed candidates.

Chuilli, Kelly v. Bridgewater Police Department 4/17/25

The Commission issued a further decision regarding relief as it relates to a Bridgewater Police Sergeant who was inappropriately bypassed for appointment to police lieutenant.

Chuilli and Zanellato v. Bridgewater Police Department 4/17/25

In a response to a request by two superior officers in the Bridgewater Police Department, the Commission voted to open an investigation into possible misconduct that resulted in an alleged “quid pro quo” arrangement between two or more BPD officers to distort the selection process for police captain.

Harkins, James v. City of Peabody 4/17/25

The Commission declined a police sergeant’s request for a retroactive effective date of his delayed promotion to lieutenant to match the promotional dates of two peers who had been promoted ahead of him based in part on there being no error or bad faith on the part of the appointing authority.

Almestica, Joshua v. City of Brockton 4/3/25

The Commission dismissed for lack of jurisdiction the appeal of a Brockton student police officer as he was not a permanent, tenured civil service employee and the recission of his conditional offer of employment did not constitute a bypass as no candidate ranked below him was selected for appointment.

Barsalou, Andrew v. Holyoke Fire Commission 4/3/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Holyoke Fire Commission to demote a suspend a Fire Captain based inappropriate conduct which he directed toward a probationary firefighter whom he was assigned to train and supervise.

Phaneuf, Angela v. Department of Correction 4/3/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Department of Correction to terminate a Correction Officer / Head Cook who failed to maintain professional boundaries with inmates and conspired with an inmate and his relative to bring synthetic cannabinoids into the facility.

Ribeiro, Lucas v. Boston Police Department 4/3/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Boston Police Department to bypass a candidate for appointment as a police officer due to his employment history, interactions with police, lack of candor, and associations with criminals.

Rodrigues, Tony v. Department of Correction 4/3/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Department of Correction (DOC) to bypass a candidate for promotional appointment to sergeant based on the undisputed fact that the candidate was and is physically unable to perform the essential function of the position.

Hartman, Brian v. Human Resources Division 4/3/25

The Commission denied a Fire Captain candidate's request to investigate HRD's decision to immediately apply a recent law change regarding eligibility to sit for promotional examinations as HRD provided sufficient notice in the exam poster and uniformly applied the new requirements.

Allender and Calderwood v. City of Amesbury Final Decision and Orders 4/3/25

The Commission issued an amended decision and orders based upon a mutual agreement of the parties.

Joseph, Marcos v. Boston Police Department 3/20/25

The Commission dismissed the bypass appeal of a candidate for Boston police officer as the candidate was bypassed for the same reasons in prior hiring cycles and the Commission recently issued a decision affirming those bypasses.

LaPalme, Nicholas v. Human Resources Division 3/20/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of HRD to deny an exam applicant ECT&E credit when the applicant failed to complete this portion of the examination prior to the deadline and because the relief requested is unlikely to change the applicant's ability to be placed on the Deputy Fire Chief eligible list.

Ortiz, Jeffrey v. City of Holyoke 3/20/25

The Commission dismissed the non-bypass equity appeal of a Holyoke police sergeant as his appeal was not timely filed with the Commission and because the alleged harm involved (being deprived of a permanent promotion while on military leave) was too speculative.

Sweet, Brian v. Department of State Police - Related Appeals Court Decision 3/7/25

The Appeals Court affirmed a Superior Court decision which held that the Commission was justified in re-opening an appeal based on compelling circumstances and affirming the decision of the State Police to terminate a State Trooper.

Abasciano, Joseph v. Boston Police Department - Decision on Motion for Reconsideration 3/6/25

The Commission denied the request of a former Boston police officer for the Commission to grant relief beyond what was already awarded in a decision issued on December 30, 2024.

Aiello, Alex v. City of Gloucester - Memorandum of Decision 3/6/25

The Superior Court referred this matter back to the Civil Service Commission for clarification in support of the Commission’s decision to reduce the City’s discipline from five days to three days. Aiello v. Massachusetts Civil Service Comm’n et al., No. 24-00248 (Suff. Sup. Ct., Feb. 20, 2025) This memorandum provid

Cenatus, Guerby v. Boston Police Department 3/6/25

The Commission allowed the bypass appeal of a candidate for Boston Police Officer as the Boston Police Department misapplied its own “automatic disqualifier” guidelines related to driving histories and was unable to show a nexus between the candidate’s driving history and his ability to serve as a police officer.

Fraser, Gregory v. Boston Police Department 3/6/25

After concluding that the Boston Police Department (BPD)’s review of a candidate for police officer was flawed and incomplete, the Commission overturned the BPD’s decision to bypass the candidate for appointment and ordered that he be reconsidered in a future hiring cycle.

Marsman, Armani v. Boston Police Department - Decision on Motion for Reconsideration 3/6/25

As there was no error or significant factor overlooked by the Commission in affirming the decision of the Boston Police Department to bypass a candidate for appointment to police officer, the Commission denied the candidate’s motion for reconsideration.

Donovan, Michael v. Human Resources Division - Decision on Motion for Reconsideration 3/6/25

Other Appeal dated March 6, 2025 Donovan, Michael v. Human Resources Division - Decision on Motion for Reconsideration 3/6/25

Sciara, Dominic and Stephen v. Town of Holbrook 3/6/25

After providing two former Holbrook firefighters with repeated opportunities to exercise their due process appeal rights, the Commission dismissed their appeals based on their failure to prosecute their appeals, including failing to appear for scheduled hearings without good cause.

Lynch, Michael v. Town of Arlington - Related Superior Court Decision 3/5/25

The Superior Court affirmed a Commission decision which concluded that the Town of Arlington complied with all applicable civil service law and rules when making a provisional appointment to the position of Parks Supervisor.

Santos, Jamie v. City of Gloucester 2/20/25

Based on the specific facts related to this appeal, the Commission dismissed the discipline appeal of a Gloucester Fire Captain, as the discipline imposed does not fall under the jurisdiction of the civil service law.

Additional Resources

We may have records that reference Civil Service Commission but originated from other agencies. Search StateReference for all records mentioning Civil Service Commission.

You may also wish to browse the agency's website at https://www.mass.gov/orgs/civil-service-commission