Civil Service Commission

Our collections contain 2,750 items and 2,752 documents where this agency is the custodian.

Newest Requests

Listed below are the newest items we have received from Civil Service Commission. Click here for the complete list.

Davis, Timothy v. City of Boston 6/26/25

The Commission dismissed the appeal of a non-selected candidate for a provisional appointment as the City’s appointment process complied with the civil service law; the selected candidate was qualified for the position; and the non-selected candidate did not possess the minimum requirements.

Ziobro, Richard v. Human Resources Division 6/26/25

The Commission allowed the examination appeal of a candidate for Medford Police Lieutenant concluding that the method employed for calculating the Appellant’s length of prior service as a MPD Patrol Officer was unreasonable and arbitrary.

Favalora, Dawn v. Human Resources Division 6/26/25

The Commission allowed, in part, the appeal of a candidate for DOC Captain, concluding that HRD erroneously denied her proper credit on the E&E component for time spent as an acting captain and ordered an evidentiary hearing on the Appellant’s claims for specialty assignment credit.

Mullane, Neal v. Boston Fire Department 6/26/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Boston Fire Department to suspend a District Fire Chief for four tours of duty based on his off-duty misconduct, including violation of the Department’s social media policy.

Lutta, Pearl v. Town of Southbridge 6/26/25

The Commission affirmed the Town of Southbridge’s decision to suspend a police officer for five days based on her failure to follow policies and procedures when responding to a report of animal abuse and her misuse of an emergency personal day.

Coderre, Paul v. City of New Bedford - Related Superior Court Decision 6/24/25

The Superior Court affirmed the Commission's decision which overturned the City of New Bedford's decision to terminate the employment of a Deputy Fire Chief.

Kneszewski, Richard v. UMASS Amherst 6/12/25

The Commission dismissed the appeal of a UMASS Amherst employee seeking reclassification to the position of Technical Specialist II (TS II) wherethe undisputed facts show that he does not perform the level distinguishing duties of a TS II, and the request is more closely related to a change in pay grade.

Lacher, Glenn v. City of Lowell 6/12/25

The Commission dismissed the appeal of a Lowell Police Officer as the Commission lacks jurisdiction to hear appeals related to a written reprimand.

Porcher-Wells, Jillliane v. Department of Children and Families 6/12/25

The Commission dismissed the appeal of a Clerk IV who was terminated from DCF as she never attained civil service permanency in any position, including Clerk IV, thus divesting the Commission of jurisdiction regarding this termination.

Perron, Jason v. Westfield Police Commission 6/12/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Westfield Police Commission to bypass a candidate for sergeant regarding one candidate but overturned a second bypass due to procedural flaws and indicia of impermissible bias

Brito, Adolfo v. Boston Police Department 6/12/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Boston Police Department to deny a candidate's request to take a make-up for one component of a delegated sergeant examination as the candidate's outside employment commitment did not justify granting the request.

Lazzara, Denise v. Human Resources Division 6/12/25

The Commission affirmed HRD's decision to deny a DOC Captain candidate's multi-pronged examination appeal.

Peckham, Christopher v. Department of Correction and HRD 6/12/25

The Commission denied a 2-part appeal brought by a candidate who took the Correction Officer II examination as did not first make a timely request for review with HRD and because he did not the meet the definition of a veteran.

Schlieman, William v. Human Resources Division 6/12/25

A majority of the Commission allowed the examination appeal of a Brockton Police Lieutenant, concluding that, under the specific facts of this case, the Appellant’s time as a UMass Lowell police officer should be properly credited toward determining his eligibility for a 2-point, 25-year preference.

Willliams, Gregory v. Human Resources Division 6/12/25

The Commission denied an examination appeal brought by a candidate who took the 2025 Boston Fire Department (BFD) Fire Lieutenant promotional examination but failed to complete the ECT&E component by filing the required ECT&E on-line claim.

Gurfinkel, Jonathan v. Human Resources Division 6/12/25

The Commission, after thorough review, denied a firefighter candidate's request to investigate whether HRD erred by removing his Newton residency preference after HRD discovered that it was granted as a result of administrative error.

White, Dominique v. Boston Police Department 5/29/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Boston Police Department to bypass a candidate for appointment based on her driving history, poor work history and criminal history.

Cote, Michael v. Human Resources Division 5/29/25

The Commission allowed the examination appeal of a candidate who had taken the promotional examination for Environmental Police Officer D (Lieutenant) and ordered that HRD grant him E&E credit for his prior outside law enforcement experience.

Ransom, Marie v. Department of Revenue 5/15/25

The Commission denied the reclassification appeal of a DOR employee as she was unable to show that she performed the level-distinguishing duties of the next higher title of Program Coordinator III more than 50% of the time.

Botelho, Matthew v. Town of Fairhaven 5/15/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Town of Fairhaven to bypass a candidate for Police Chief based on the selected candidate’s superior performance during a well-designed, structured interview process, which demonstrated that the selected candidate was the better choice to lead the Police Department.

Darmofal and Sniezek v. Town of Fairhaven & HRD 5/15/25

The Commission, after a thorough review of legislative history and the actions by the Town of Fairhaven, concluded that, based on the facts presented here, a Town Meeting vote was not sufficient to remove the Town from civil service as the Town originally adopted civil service through a ballot question.

Denis, Harly v. Boston Police Department 5/15/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Boston Police Department to bypass a candidate for appointment as a permanent, full-time police officer based on the candidate’s undisputed – and recent – poor judgment in impermissibly assisting an individual with taking a learner’s permit exam.

Watt, Adam v. Boston Police Department 5/15/25

The Commission affirmed the decision of the Boston Police Department to bypass a candidate for police officer based on his poor driving record, including two separate operating under the influence charges.

Helms, Gregory v. Human Resources Division 5/15/25

The Commission denied the appeal of a candidate who took the September 2024 Police Sergeant examination and received an “INCOMPLETE” on the ECT&E component which resulted in his failing to pass the examination.

Additional Resources

We may have records that reference Civil Service Commission but originated from other agencies. Search StateReference for all records mentioning Civil Service Commission.

You may also wish to browse the agency's website at https://www.mass.gov/orgs/civil-service-commission