On November 1, 2015, the states Human Resource Division (HRD) established an eligible list of those who passed the civil service police exam, including the Appellant. At the Departments request, HRD issued certification 04401on February 22, 2017 and March 2, 2017. The Appellant was ranked 71st on certification 04401 among those willing to accept employment.

Ittleman DECISION The Appellant, Antony Yan, acting pursuant to G.L c. 31, 2(b), appealed to the Civil Service Commission (Commission) from the decision of the City of Lowell (Lowell), reviewed and approved by the Massachusetts Human Resources Division (HRD), to bypass him for appointment as a Police Officer with the Lowell Police Department (LPD).

Deputy General Counsel Human Resources Division 100 Cambridge Street, Suite 600 Boston, MA 02114 Date: June 1, 2023 2

Firm/Organization Name Human Resources Division EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION (if any) 17. Name NAGE Unit 1 Local 292 18. Telephone Number 617-376-0220 1 19,20,21,22. Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) 159 Burgin Parkway Quincy MA 02169 23. FAX Number 617-376-0285 EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION'S LABOR RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVE 24. Name Araba Adjei-Koranteng 25. Telephone Number 671-376-7275 26,27,28,29.

Deputy General Counsel Human Resources Division 100 Cambridge Street, Suite 600 Boston, MA 02114 Date: June 1, 2023 2

Firm/Organization Name Human Resources Division EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION (if any) 17. Name NAGE Unit 3 (Local 219) 18. Telephone Number 617-376-0220 1 19,20,21,22. Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) 159 Burgin Parkway Quincy MA 02169 23. FAX Number 617-376-0285 EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION'S LABOR RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVE 24. Name Araba Adjei-Koranteng 25. Telephone Number 617-376-7275 26,27,28,29.

Deputy General Counsel Human Resources Division 100 Cambridge Street, Suite 600 Boston, MA 02114 Date: June 1, 2023 2

Firm/Organization Name Human Resources Division EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION (if any) 17. Name NAGE Unit 6 (Local 207) 18. Telephone Number 617-376-0220 1 19,20,21,22. Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) 159 Burgin Parkway Quincy MA 02169 23. FAX Number 617-376-0285 EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION'S LABOR RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVE 24. Name Araba Adjei-Koranteng 25. Telephone Number 611-376-7275 26,27,28,29.

Deputy General Counsel Human Resources Division 100 Cambridge Street, Suite 600 Boston, MA 02114 Date: June 1, 2023 2

Firm/Organization Name Human Resources Division EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION (if any) 17. Name NAGE Unit 6 (Local 282) 18. Telephone Number 617-376-0220 1 19,20,21,22. Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) 159 Burgin Parkway Quincy MA 02169 23. FAX Number 617-376-0285 EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION'S LABOR RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVE 24. Name Araba Adjei-Koranteng 25. Telephone Number 617-376-7275 26,27,28,29.

Telephone Number John Marra, Esq. 617-727-3555 Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) Human Resources Division, One Ashburton Place, Boston, MA 6. Employee Organization (if any): Alliance/AFSCME/SEIU, Local 509 8. 5. Fax Number 02108 617-727-1477 7. Representative to contact 9.

Respectfully Submitted for the Commonwealth by Its Attorney, /s/Wendy Chu________________________ Wendy Chu Assistant General Counsel Human Resources Division One Ashburton Place, Room 207 Boston, MA 02108 617-878-9766 8 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Wendy Chu, certify that a true copy of the foregoing RESPONDENTS RESPONSE has been served upon James Hykel, Esq., counsel for the Charging Party, by electronic mail (pdf) and first-class mail on January 20

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS EXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION ONE ASHBURTON PLACE, BOSTON, MA 02108 DEVAL L. PATRICK Governor GLEN SHOR Secretary TIMOTHY P. MURRAY Lieutenant Governor PAUL DIETL Chief Human Resources Officer VIA HAND DELIVERY MAIL May 29, 2013 Edward Srednicki Executive Secretary Department of Labor Relations Charles F.

On June 13, 2012, USW requested that MassDOT provide all letters that MassDOT sent to HR Director Swee Wong-Wagner requesting that the Commonwealth of Massachusettss Human Resources Division create new job titles within Units B, D, and E. USW sought this information to allow it to determine if MassDOT has fulfilled its obligations under the MLIA and to assess whether USW must take any action in furtherance of the creation of the new titles.

and enrollees from the last two years; 4) A copy of the contract between the Employer provider; and the class 5) A copy of billing records for the class; and 6) All documents related to the creation, approval implementation process of the No Show form. 12. process, and By emails dated June 13, 2012 and July 2, 2012, the Union asked the Employer to provide all of the letters that the Employer sent to the Human Resources Director requesting that the Human

Butler Labor Counsel Human Resources Division One Ashburton Place, Rm. 211 Boston, MA 02108 (617) 878-9785 Page 1 of 16 I. EXHIBITS: The parties agreed to the submission of the following joint exhibits: 1. Collective Bargaining Agreement . 2. November 7, 2016 Notice of Reassignment to Gina Bartlett. 3. February 10, 2017 email from Pam Fitzpatrick to Darrell Cole. 4. February 14, 2017 email from Darrell Cole to Pam Fitzpatrick. 5.