Bay Community College + Massasoit Community College * Middlesex Community College * Mount Wachusett Community College * Northern Essex Community College * North Shore Community College + Quinsigamond Community College + Roxbury Community College * Springfield Technical Community College @ Prev ov Reeves Paen CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I certify that on April 26, 2012 I served a copy of the attached Response by hand to Miles Stern, MTA Date: Consultant

Bay Community College * Massasoit Community College = Middlesex Community College + Mount Wachuser: Community College * Northern Essex Community College + North Shore Community College * Quinsigamond Community College + Roxbury Community College + Springfield Technical Community College @ Praren ox Recrcurp Pare tabbies* EXHIBIT MASSACHUSETTS COMMUNITY COLLEG OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL fs MIDDLESEX COMMUNITY COLLEGE

Bay Community College + Massusoit Community College * Middlesex Community College Mount Wachusett Community College Northern Essex Community College * North Shore Community College * Quinsigamond Community College + Raxbury Community College + Springheld Technical Comnmmnity College Paxny on Revrcun Parce COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS AFSCME Council 93 Charging Party v. ) ) ) ) ) Case No.

Bay Community College * Massasait Community College Middlesex C ity College Mount Wachusett Community College + Northern Essex Community College North Shore Community College + Quinsigamond Community College * Roxbury Community College * Springfield Technical Community College eo) Pentre on Reeveuro Pare COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS AFSCME Council 93 ) ) Charging Party =) ) ) v. Case No.

Bay Community College * Massasoit Community College + Middlesex Community College * Mount Wachusett Community College Northern Essex Community College * North Shore Community College Quinsigamond Community College * Roxbury Community College Springfield Technical Comnntnity College 1) Procroos Revcun Paper COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS Massachusetts Community College ) Council Charging Party V. ) Case No. ) ) SUP-13-3359

College Stephen Fabbrucci, Vice President of Human Resources DLR/SUP/NECC/13.335933465.22.}4ef Berkshire Community College + Bristol Community College Bunker Hill Communily College Cape Cod Community College Grecipicht Community College * Holvoke Community College * Mass, Bay Community College * Massasoit Community College + Middlesex Community College * Mount Wachusett Community College Northern Essex Community College North Shore Community College + Quinsigamond

The Appellant holds a High School Equivalency/GED diploma and has attended classes at Quinsigamond Community College. He holds certificates in Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) Paving Inspector, Concrete Inspector, and ACI (American Concrete Institute) Concrete Field Testing. (Testimony of Appellant; Exhibit 4) 3.

Bay Community College + Massasoit Community College Middlesex Community College + Mount Wachusett Community College Northern Essex Community College + North Shore Community College Quinsigamond Community College + Roxbury Community College + Springfield Technical Community College COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE DIVISION OF LABOR RELATIONS RRR KK ARK KK KKK K KR K KKK KR KR KR RK KR RIK ~ In the matter of * * Nov Bal Shore Ceom mudi, Respondent

Bay Community College * Massasoit Community College + Middlesex Community College + Mount Wachusett Community College * Northern Essex Community College + North Shore Community College * Quinsigamond Community College + Roxbury Community College + Springfield Technical Community College @ Prom on Revere Pare COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE DIVISION OF LABOR RELATIONS In the matter of ; Mace / MTAT OLE .

Community College John Casey, Assistant General Counsel SUP/NECC/15-4349/L2DLR 1 54349-e.f Berkshire Community College * Bristol Community College Bunker Hill Community College * Cape Cod Community College Greenfield Community College * Holyoke Community College + Mass, Bay Community College + Massasoit Community College * Middlesex Community College * Mount Wachusett Community College Northern Es ex Community College + North Shore Community College * Quinsigamond

Bay Community College * Massasoit Community College * Middlesex Community College * Mount Wachusett Community College * Northern Essex Community College + North Shore Community College * Quinsigamond Community College + Roxbury Community College + Springfield Technical Community College @ Pro ow Reeveuen Pare COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS ) ) ) ) ) ) AFSCME Council 93 Charging Party Vv. Case No.