Clifford & Kenny 171 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02339 Commissioner: Christopher C.

Clifford oe atid Kenny, LLP 1 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02339 BBO#630769 DATED: May 4, 2015 Certificate of Service Ihereby certify that I forwarded a copy of the foregoing document on May 4, 2015, to Patrick Bryant, Esq., 18 Tremont St., Ste. 500, Boston, MA 02108, counsel for the charging party, by email. John J. Clifford 2 Town of Scituates Answer MUP-15-4311

Director - Charles Homer Zip Code: 02339-1215 Hanover, MA Telephone: (781) 878-8822 Fax: (781) 982-0281 Name of Representative: Lorna Hebert, Esq.

Clifford & Kenny, LLP 171 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02339 RE: MUP-14-4207, Town of Rockland and Rockland Fire Fighters Union, Local 1602 Dear Mr. Hykel and Ms.

Clifford & Kenny 171 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02339 Commissioner: Paul M. Stein DECISION The Appellant, Michael R. Caggiano, appealed to the Civil Service Commission (Commission), from the decision of the Fire Chief of the Marshfield Fire Department (MFD), as Appointing Authority, imposing a one-day (24 hour tour) suspension from his position as a MFD Firefighter/Paramedic.

Clifford Clifford and Kenny, LLP 171 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02339 BBO#630769 DATED: July 20, 2015 3 Respondent City of Fall Rivers Answer, MUP -15-4448 Certificate of Service I hereby certify that I forwarded a copy of the foregoing document on July 20, 2015, to Leah Barrault, Esq., 2 Liberty Square, 10th Floor, Boston, MA 02108, counsel for the charging party, by email. John J. Clifford 4 Respondent City of Fall Rivers Answer, MUP -15-4448

Clifford & Kenny, LLP 171 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02399 Administrative Magistrate: Kenneth J. Forton, Esq.

Hanover School Committee By: Dated: Sa AFSCME, May 25, 2016 Dated: by: Council 93, Local 1700 Aiphectc he nuhile May 25, 2016 188 Broadway, Hanover, MA 02339 @ www.hanoverschools.org @ Telephone 781-878-0786 @ Facsimile 781-871-3374 The mission of the Hanover Public Schools is to guide every student to thrive in a global saciety.

. | Dated: May 25, 2016 188 Broadway, Hanover, MA 02339 @ www.hanoverschools.org @ Telephone 781-878-0786 Facsimile 781-871-337 4 The mission of the Hanover Public Schools is to guide every student to thrive in a global society,

Correia II Work ini ti Agent Bargaining Name padid Address of Collective tone # Clifford & Kenny LLP 171 Rockland Street Hanover, MA 02339 Phone # 781-924-5796 Work Information on Dispute Date of Expiration of Current or Most Recent Collective Bargaining Agreement 06/30/15 Number of Bargaining Sessions Held to Date and Date of Last Session 8 sessions, last session 09/20/16 Statement of Issues in Dispute (Use another page if necessary) see attached