.; See also, City of Boston, 15 MLC 1587 (1989), aff'd sub nom, Boston Police Superior Officers Federation v. City of Boston, 414 Mass. 458, 466 (1993). {Practice Areas/LABOR/05875/12162/A3203709.DOCX} 6 1. The Towns concerns are legitimate and substantial as the requested information constitutes confidential personnel records that are exempt from public disclosure and are subject to privacy protections under M.G.L. c. 214 1B.

If such an appeal is filed, this CD should be used to transcribe the hearing. 2 FINDINGS OF FACT Respondents Exhibits 1 through 16 (including rebuttal cases), and the Appellants Exhibits 1 through 22 were entered into evidence at the hearing.4 Based on all of the exhibits, the testimony of the following witnesses: Called by the Respondent: Nicholas Green, Correction Officer, Internal Affairs Unit, DOC Jason Wheeler, Police Officer, Easton Police Department

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.

A unions freedom to regulate its internal affairs must give way to certain overriding interests implicit in the Law. Id.