.: D1-07-234 DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION, Respondent DECISION After careful review and consideration, the Civil Service Commission voted at an executive session on July 23, 2009 to acknowledge receipt of the report of the Administrative Law Magistrate dated June 5, 2009. No comments were received by the Commission from either party.

ET AL., Defendants, Appellees, MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION, ET AL., Defendants. Before Boudin, Howard and Thompson, Circuit Judges. JUDGMENT Entered: September 5, 2012 Plaintiffs-appellants Andrew Arvanitis and Edward Jacobs appeal from the dismissal of their amended complaint. Our review is de novo, accepting all well-pleaded facts in the amended complaint as true and "indulging all reasonable inferences." Davison v.

Department of Correction P.O. Box 946, Industries Drive Norfolk, MA. 01545 RE: Benjamin McGuiness and Richard Mullen v. Department of Correction, D-05-53, D-05- 54, CS-08148 Dear Chairman Bowman, Attorneys Pfaff and Hughes: Enclosed please find the Recommended Decision that is being issued today.

D1-06-347 DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION, Respondent Appellants Attorney: Melvin Norris, Esq. 260 Boston Post Road, Suite 7 Wayland, MA 01778 (508) 358-3305 attorneynorris@yahoo.com Respondents Attorney: Amy Hughes, Esq. Department of Correction 70 Franklin Street, Suite 600 Boston, MA 02110-1300 (617) 727-3300, ext. 167 amy.hughes@state.ma.us Commissioner: Christopher C.

of Corrections Bristol County Sheriff's Office Stonehill College Revere Police Department Hampden Police Department Chicopee Police Department Sunderland Police Department Dalton Police Department Lenox Police Department Boston Police Department Boston Housing Authority Lowell Police Department Lowell Police Department Pittsfield Police Department Lenox Police Department Plymouth Police Department Dighton Police Department Worcester County Sheriff's

University Clarksburg Police Department Clinton Police Department Cohasset Police Department College of the Holy Cross Colrain Police Department Concord Police Department Conway Police Department Cummington Police Department Curry College Dalton Police Department Danvers Police Department Dartmouth Police Department Dean College Dedham Police Department Deerfield Police Department Dennis Police Department Department of Conservation and Recreation Department

University Clarksburg Police Department Clinton Police Department Cohasset Police Department College of the Holy Cross Colrain Police Department Concord Police Department Conway Police Department Cummington Police Department Curry College Dalton Police Department Danvers Police Department Dartmouth Police Department Dean College Dedham Police Department Deerfield Police Department Dennis Police Department Department of Conservation and Recreation Department

Framingham Police SWAT operator 2000-2002 Team Leader 2002-2005 and Executive Officer(2005-2010) Past Employment- Ma Department of Corrections Correction Officer 1989-1993 Education 1991-1994 Westfield State College -Master of Science, Criminal Justice 1985-1989 Westfield State College -Bachelor of Science, Criminal Justice 1981-1985 Framingham North High Comprehensive Professional Training MPI Executive Leadership Series -2015 LEEDA-Executive Leadership

OF CORRECTION STATE ETHICS COMMISSION OFFICE OF THE STATE TREASURER SECRETARY OF STATE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICE OF THE STATE TREASURER EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE STATE AUDITORS OFFICE EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION EXECUTIVE OFFICE for ADMINISTRATION and FINANCE EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF PUBLIC SAFETY & HOMELAND

(EOL) EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF PUBLIC SAFETY & SECURITY (EOPSS) (EPS)(911) Department of Correction (DOC) Dept. of Criminal Justice Information Services (CHS) <5 Department of Fire Services (DFS) MA Emergency Management Agency (CDA) (MEMA) <5 Massachusetts National Guard (MIL) Massachusetts Parole Board (PAR) Massachusetts State Police (POL) Municipal Police Training Committee (CJT) Office of the Chief Medical Examiner (CME) Sex Offender Registry Board