Labor Organization's Representative's Address (street, city/town, state, and zip code) 7 Bedford Street, Suite 1, Burlington Ma 01803 19 18. Fax Number (781-425-3579) This Petition is being filed: (check one) Jointly (If [ | Employer Only(if [| checked, complete sections 26 through 31 and skip section 32) checked, complete sections 26 - 28 & 32, skip sections 26-28) vel Labor Org.

Town of Burlington, 60 Mass. App. Ct. 914, 915 (2004). Analysis Holyoke identified two (2) issues for bypassing Ms. Cardona: 1) her untruthfulness for failing to disclose that she was arraigned in Dudley District Court on criminal charges in 2007; and 2) her poor response to an interview question. I listened carefully to Ms. Cardonas testimony and reviewed all of the documents submitted, including her 2011 and 2014 employment applications.

Unions reference to Town of Burlington v. Labor Relations Commission et al, 390 Mass. 157 (1983) is misplaced and irrelevant. That matter involved the cessation of using police officers as prosecutors and assigning those duties outside to the town counsel thus taking the position out of the realm and context of collective bargaining altogether. Such is not the case in the instant matter.

Town of Burlington, 60 Mass.App.Ct. 914, 915 (2004). Analysis Mr. Andujar was a good witness. He was sincerely polite and professional throughout the appeal process and appears to have all of the characteristics necessary to serve in the important position of reserve or regular Holyoke police officer. The City apparently agreed with that assessment, having offered Mr.

Town of Burlington and another v. McCarthy, 60 Mass. App. Ct. 914, 915 (2004). Disputed facts regarding alleged prior misconduct of an applicant must be considered under the preponderance of the evidence standard of review as set forth in the SJCs recent decision in Boston Police Dept v.

Respectfully submitted, BOSTON SCHOOL COMMITTEE By its attorney, eee Virginia Casey Goscinak BBO #204490 Office of Labor Relations 26 Court Street Boston, MA 02108 Tel: (617) 635-9325 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true copy of the above docume tag rvd upon Mark Esposito; Esq., the attorney of record, at his place of business, Duddy,25 Mall Road; Burlington, MA 01803, by fax and first-class mail on the] (d Z of May 20120 Virginia Casey

Respectfully submitted, BOSTON SCHOOL COMMITTEE By its attorney, 4 on Virginia Casey Goscinak BBO #204490 Office of Labor Relations 26 Court Street Boston, MA 02108 Tel: (617) 635-9325 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true copy of the above doct ment erved upon Mark Esposite;Esq., the attorney of record, at his place of business, Diyez Duddy,Z5 Mall ; Burlington, MA 01803, by fax and first-class mail ers May 2012 Lo Virginia Casey Goscinak

Sincerely, ) Yi Ao Carol Markland, Staff Representative AFSCME Council93 North Shore Area Office 7 Bedford Street, Unit A, Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: 781-246-5300 Fax: 781-425-3579 * www.afscmecouncil93.org "

Debbie Schofield North Shore Secretary AFSCME Council 93 7 Bedford Street, Unit A Burlington MA 01803 Phone 781-425-7865 Fax 781-425-3579

FAX Number Burlington MA 01803 781-425-3579 (15. E-mail Address 16. Firm/Organization Name scronin@afseme93.org AFSCME Council 93 EMPLOYER 18. Name 19. Telephone Number Dracut School Commitee 978-957-2660 20. Address 2063 Lakeview Ave 24. FAX Number 617-556-8989 21,22,23. City/town, State, ZIP Code Dracut MA 01826 LABOR RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVE 25. Name Joan Stein 26. Title Attorney 27. Address 31.

Unit A Burlington, MA 01803 Phone (781) 425-7869 Fax (781) 425-3579