Ralph appeals from a judgment of the Superior Court affirming the decision of the Civil Service Commission (commission) 1 Human Resources Division. 2 disallowing Sergeant Ralph additional points on a promotional examination for twenty-five years of service under G. L. c. 31, 59, and additional points for previous experience in the position sought under G. L. c. 31, 22.

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEMORANDUM OF DECISION AND ORDER ON PARTIES CROSS MOTIONS FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS In this action, the plaintiff, Thomas Ralph (Ralph), appeals the decision of the Civil Service Commission (CSC) allowing the Human Resources Divisions (HRD) motions to dismiss Ralph's consolidated appeals of HRDs denials of his requests for two additional training and experience points on four civil service promotional examinations. ' Before

G1-18-065 HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION & BOSTON FIRE DEPARTMENT, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Pro Se Abbymael Rodriguez Appearance for Human Resources Division: Patrick Butler, Esq. Human Resources Division One Ashburton Place Boston, MA 02108 Appearance for Boston Fire Department: Jordana Westerman, Esq. City of Boston Office of Labor Relations 1 City Hall Square Boston, MA 02204 Commissioner: Christopher C.

HAMPDEN_COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT FILED _ i ERIK SUNNY PLAINTIFF OCT 0:8 2021 vs. ie CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION CLERK OF COURTS - AND HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION DEFENDANTS . .

Services Department 194 Media Service Department 145 Treasurer/Collector Department Inspectional Services Division 241 Inspectional Service Department 244 Weights & Measures Department 511 - Public Health Department 174 - Planning & Community Development 172 Community & Economic Development 171 Conservation Commission 175 Planning Board 173 Zoning Board of Appeals 174 Planning & Community Development Economic Development Industrial Corporation (EDIC) Human

202,993 2,357,730 389,152 606,323 1,035,264 $ 1,026,120 $ 1,033,946 $ 1,125,543 $ 1,162,847 $ 1,148,357 - $ - 2 City of Framingham FY2021 Budget 244 Weights & Measures Department 511 - Public Health Department 174 - Planning & Community Development 172 Community & Economic Development 171 Conservation Commission 175 Planning Board 173 Zoning Board of Appeals 174 Planning & Community Development Economic Development Industrial Corporation (EDIC) Human

Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector Treasurer Collector General Government Division General Government Division General Government Division 00000 No Project 00000 No Project 00000 No Project Legal Department Legal Department Legal Department Human

COMMONWEALTH|OF MASSACHUSETTS, and PAUL DIETL, in his capacity as Personnel Administrator for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Human Resources Division, Defendants MEMORANDUM OF DECISION AND ORDER ON PLAINTIFFS EMERGENCY MOTION TO ENFORCE THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND/OR FOR A TEMPORARY INJUNCTION Thirteen years of litigation culminated in what was believed to have been a remedy and resolution of this class action challenging the Police sergeants

C-14-287 HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION & DIVISION OF INSURANCE, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Pro Se Mary Ellen Thompson, Esq. Appearance for Respondents: Melissa Thomson, Esq. Michele Heffernan, Esq. Labor Counsel Human Resources Division One Ashburton Place, Room 301 Boston, MA 02108 Commissioner: Cynthia A.

Administrator for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Human Resources Division, Defendants. ORDER APPROVING CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT | ne The parties have submitted to the Court a j ointat Motion for Final Approval of | Partial Settlement Agreement (the Motion. The Motion seeks final. approval. pursuant to Mass. R. Civ.-P. 23(c) of the parties Classs Action Settlement Agreement (the .

C-14-294 HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION & DIVISION OF INSURANCE, Respondents Appearance for Appellant: Pro Se Mindy Merow Rubin, Esq. Appearance for Respondents: Melissa Thomson, Esq. Michele Heffernan, Esq. Labor Counsel Human Resources Division One Ashburton Place, Room 301 Boston, MA 02108 Commissioner: Cynthia A.

NO. 0984CV00576 : SPENCER TATUM, GWENDOLYN BROWN, LOUIS ROSARIO JR., and FRANCISCO BAEZ, individually and on behalf of a class of individuals similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. ' : COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, and PAUL DIETL, in his capacity as Personnel Administrator for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Human Resources Division, Defendants. .