COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matters of KKKKKKEKKEKEKEKEREEKREKIEEKREREREEERKEKKKEKKK ARK KKK TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND Case Nos:.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 TOWN OF PROVINCETOWN AND Case Nos:.: PROVINCETOWN SCHOOL COMMITTEE, MUP-12-1705 MUP-12-1706 MUP-12-1707 MUP-12-1734 MUP-12-1735 MUP-12-1736 FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, and FALMOUTH

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD In the Matters of RRERERERREERREHEERREREREERERA ARK KKKKKAKKKaEKKKRKKKKaKE TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Case Nos.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 Case Nos.: MUP-12-1705 and FALMOUTH EDUCATORS ASSOCIATION AND AFSCME, COUNCIL 93 TOWN OF PROVINCETOWN

(CQ COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYEE RELATIONS BOARD TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Respondents Case Nos.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 Case Nos.

Address (street and No., city/town, apts and ZIP code) PO Box 867 East Falmouth Ma 02536 23. FAX Number EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION'S LABOR RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVE 24, Name Arthur O'Connell 25. Telephone Number 617-448-7231 26,27,28,29. Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) 30. FAX Number PO Box 867 East Falmouth Ma 02536 31. E-mail Address 32. Firm/Organization djmc24@gmail.com Name EPOA 33.

Town of Falmouth v. Civil Service Commn, 447 Mass. 814, 823 (2006) and cases cited. The commissions task . . . is not to be accomplished on a wholly blank slate. After making its de novo findings of fact . . . the commission does not act without regard to the previous decision of the appointing authority, which may include an adverse inference against a complainant who fails to testify at the hearing before the appointing authority.

Town of Falmouth, 39 MLC 376, 384 (2013). Where a position shares a community of interest with more than one bargaining unit, the Board places the position in the unit with which 7 it shares the greater community of interest. Town of Falmouth, Ibid at 384 quoting Board of Trustees, University of Massachusetts, 31 MLC 209, 215 (2005). The Dispatch Supervisor will share a community of interest with other City of Chelsea supervisory employees.

Town of Falmouth v. Civil Service Commn, 447 Mass. 814, 823 (2006).

COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND AFSCME LOCAL 1636, UNIT B (July 1, 2014 June 30, 2017) TABLE OF CONTENTS Article 1 Recognition Article 2 Management Rights Article 3 Personnel File Article 4 Performance Evaluation & Step Increase 41 Step Increases 4.2 Performance Records Article 5 Job Descriptions & Reclassification Procedure Article 6 Hours of Work 6.1 Hours of Work 6,2 Overtime & Compensatory Time 63 Call Back 6.4 Details 6.5

Town of Falmouth v. Civil Service Commn, 447 Mass. 814 (2006). The role of the Commission is to determine whether the appointing authority has sustained its burden of proving that there was reasonable justification for the action taken by the appointing authority. City of Cambridge v. Civil Service Commn, 43 Mass.App.Ct. 300, 304, rev.den., 426 Mass. 1102, (1997). See also City of Leominster v.

See, e.g., Town of Falmouth v. Civil Service Commn, 447 Mass. 814, 823, (2006); Police Dept of Boston v. Collins, 48 Mass.App.Ct. 411, rev.den., 726 N.E.2d 417 8 (2000); McIsaac v. Civil Service Commn, 38 Mass App.Ct.473,477 (1995); Town of Watertown v. Arria, 16 Mass.App Ct. 331,334, rev.den.,390 Mass. 1102 (1983).

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matters of KKKKKKEKKEKEKEKEREEKREKIEEKREREREEERKEKKKEKKK ARK KKK TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND Case Nos:.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 TOWN OF PROVINCETOWN AND Case Nos:.: PROVINCETOWN SCHOOL COMMITTEE, MUP-12-1705 MUP-12-1706 MUP-12-1707 MUP-12-1734 MUP-12-1735 MUP-12-1736 FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, and FALMOUTH

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD In the Matters of RRERERERREERREHEERREREREERERA ARK KKKKKAKKKaEKKKRKKKKaKE TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Case Nos.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 Case Nos.: MUP-12-1705 and FALMOUTH EDUCATORS ASSOCIATION AND AFSCME, COUNCIL 93 TOWN OF PROVINCETOWN

(CQ COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYEE RELATIONS BOARD TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Respondents Case Nos.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 Case Nos.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matters of REKKKRERKEKKEKRKKREEEKREKEKEREEEKEKKEKKEKKEA KKK KKK KK K TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND Case Nos:: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 TOWN OF PROVINCETOWN AND Case Nos:.: PROVINCETOWN SCHOOL COMMITTEE, MUP-12-1705 MUP-12-1706 MUP-12-1707 MUP-12-1734 MUP-12-1735 MUP-12-1736 FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, and FALMOUTH

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD In the Matters of RRERERERREERREHEERREREREERERA ARK KKKKKAKKKaEKKKRKKKKaKE TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Case Nos.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 Case Nos.: MUP-12-1705 and FALMOUTH EDUCATORS ASSOCIATION AND AFSCME, COUNCIL 93 TOWN OF PROVINCETOWN

(CQ COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYEE RELATIONS BOARD TOWN OF FALMOUTH AND FALMOUTH SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Respondents Case Nos.: MUP-12-1749 MUP-12-1752 MUP-12-1753 MUP-12-1754 MUP-12-1755 MUP-12-1756 MUP-12-1758 MUP-12-1750 MUP-12-1751 Case Nos.