D-05-271 CITY OF HOLYOKE, Respondent Appellants Attorney: Marshall T. Moriarty, Esq. Moriarty & Connor, LLC 101 State Street, Suite 501 Springfield, MA 01103-2070 (413) 827-0777 Respondents Attorney: Melissa Shea, Esq. Sullivan, Hayes and Quinn One Monarch Place, Suite 1200 Springfield, MA 01144-1200 (413) 736-4536 Hearing Officer: John J.

CITY OF HOLYOKE, Respondent CITY OF SOMERVILLE, Respondent DECISION Pursuant to G.L. c. 31, 43, the Chair of the Civil Service Commission (Commission) assigned the Commissions General Counsel to serve as presiding officer over a multi-day evidentiary hearing into those issues raised by the Appellant, former Holyoke police officer Rafael Roca, in conjunction with his employment termination appeal.

See also City of Holyoke, 28 MLC 393, MUP-2475 (June 14, 2002) (noncompliance with the time limits in an agreement constituted a repudiation of that agreement); Board of Trustees of Higher Education, 28 MLC 235, SUP-4512 (January 23, 2002) (delayed provision of information constituted a repudiation of an agreement to provide information by a specific date).

Name (print) Signature Title (if any) Field Representative Maryelen Calderwood Address (street and no., city/town, state, and ZIP code) Telephone Number MTA 55 Bobala Rd. , Suite 3, Holyoke, MA 02171 413-535-2415 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have served a copy of this Charge of Prohibited Practice on the following representative of the opposing party.

See also City of Holyoke, 28 MLC 393, MUP-2475 (June 14, 2002) (noncompliance with the time limits in an agreement constituted a repudiation of that agreement); Board of Trustees of Higher Education, 28 MLC 235, SUP-4512 (January 23, 2002) (delayed provision of information constituted a repudiation of an agreement to provide information by a specific date).

Name (print) Signature Title (if any) Field Representative Maryelen Calderwood Address (street and no., city/town, state, and ZIP code) Telephone Number MTA 55 Bobala Rd. , Suite 3, Holyoke, MA 02171 413-535-2415 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have served a copy of this Charge of Prohibited Practice on the following representative of the opposing party.

See also City of Holyoke, 28 MLC 393, MUP-2475 (June 14, 2002) (noncompliance with the time limits in an agreement constituted a repudiation of that agreement); Board of Trustees of Higher Education, 28 MLC 235, SUP-4512 (January 23, 2002) (delayed provision of information constituted a repudiation of an agreement to provide information by a specific date).

Name (print) Signature Title (if any) Field Representative Maryelen Calderwood Address (street and no., city/town, state, and ZIP code) Telephone Number MTA 55 Bobala Rd. , Suite 3, Holyoke, MA 02171 413-535-2415 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have served a copy of this Charge of Prohibited Practice on the following representative of the opposing party.

C/O HARDING & CARBONE 3903 BELLAIRE BLVD HOUSTON, TX 77025 56-50-0 58-18-0 GUILLAUME MARC H 2885 SANFORD AVE SW #25880 GRANDVILLE, MI 49418 27 29 UNION ST 67-90-0 64-38-0 HEMPSTEAD MICHAEL HEMPSTEAD MARIA 84 BANCROFT ROAD NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 52 58 MAPLE ST 67-81-0 56-53-0 HOLMES TOBY A O PO BOX 1431 GREENFIELD, MA 01302 16 CONGRESS ST 52-11-0 76-23-0 HOMESAVERS COUNCIL 0F GREENFIELD GARDENS INC C/O MOUNT HOLYOKE MANAGEMENT LLC 667 MAIN STREET HOLYOKE

C/O HARDING & CARBONE 3903 BELLAIRE BLVD HOUSTON, TX 77025 56-50-0 58-18-0 GUILLAUME MARC H 2885 SANFORD AVE SW #25880 GRANDVILLE, MI 49418 27 29 UNION ST 67-90-0 64-38-0 HEMPSTEAD MICHAEL HEMPSTEAD MARIA 84 BANCROFT ROAD NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 52 58 MAPLE ST 67-81-0 56-53-0 HOLMES TOBY A O PO BOX 1431 GREENFIELD, MA 01302 16 CONGRESS ST 52-11-0 76-23-0 HOMESAVERS COUNCIL 0F GREENFIELD GARDENS INC C/O MOUNT HOLYOKE MANAGEMENT LLC 667 MAIN STREET HOLYOKE

D1-07-255 CITY OF HOLYOKE, Respondent Appellants Attorney: Devin Moriarty, Esq. Moriarty & Connor, LLC 101 State Street Springfield, MA 01103 Appointing Authoritys Attorney: Melissa M. Shea, Esq.

D-06-30 CITY OF HOLYOKE, Respondent Appellants Attorney: Marshall T. Moriarty, Esq. Moriarty & Connor, LLC 101 State Street, Suite 501 Springfield, MA 01103 Respondents Attorney: Meghan B. Sullivan, Esq. Sullivan, Hayes & Quinn One Monarch Place, Suite 1200 Springfield, MA 01144 Hearing Officer: John J.

D-06-30 CITY OF HOLYOKE, Respondent Appellants Attorney: Marshall T. Moriarty, Esq. Moriarty & Connor, LLC 101 State Street, Suite 501 Springfield, MA 01103 Respondents Attorney: Meghan B. Sullivan, Esq. Sullivan, Hayes & Quinn One Monarch Place, Suite 1200 Springfield, MA 01144 Hearing Officer: John J.