On February 8, 2011, the states Human Resources Division (HRD), established an eligible list of candidates, upon which the Appellants name appeared. 3. On May 20, 2011, HRD forwarded Certification No. 4011021 to DOC with a sufficient number of names to meet the statutory 2n + 1 formula from which they would ultimately appoint 204 CO Is. 4.

The Appellant was notified of his bypass for appointment by the Human Resources Division (hereinafter HRD) by letter dated April 14, 2008. The appeal was timely filed, A pre-hearing conference was held on June 9, 2008.

The Appellant was notified of his bypass for appointment by the Human Resources Division (hereinafter HRD) by letter dated September 17, 2007. The appeal was timely filed. A pre-hearing conference was held on March 12, 2008. After the pre-hearing conference, the BPD filed a Motion to Dismiss the Appellants instant appeal on the basis of collateral estoppel.

As part of the pre-hearing conference, relying on documentation provided by the City and the states Human Resources Division (HRD), the parties agreed that Mr. Pratticos name appeared on Certification No. 03394 and that he was tied in the 31st rank with one other candidate who was appointed. Importantly, no candidate ranked below 31st was appointed from this Certification.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS EXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION ONE ASHBURTON PLACE, BOSTON, MA 02108 JAY GONZALEZ DEVAL L. PATRICK Governor Secretary TEL.#: TIMOTHY P. MURRAY Lieutenant Governor TO: 617-727-3555 CC: Mark E.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS EXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION ONE ASHBURTON PLACE, BOSTON, MA 02108 JAY GONZALEZ DEVAL L. PATRICK Governor TIMOTHY P. MURRAY TEL.#: 617-727-3555 - FAX #: Secretary PAUL DIETL 617-727-3252 Chief Human Resources Officer Lieutenant Governor TO: Julayne Lazar Department of Revenue FROM: CC: Mark E. D'Angelo, Director Kate Kelly NAGE ma PPsS=1f - Ea PFS) CASE?

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS EXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION ONE ASHBURTON PLACE, BOSTON, MA 02108 DEVAL L. PATRICK JAY GONZALEZ Governor Secretary TIMOTHY P. MURRAY TEL.#: 617-727-3555 - FAX #: 617-727-3252 PAUL DIETL Lieutenant Governor TO: Chief Human Resources Officer Gary Murphy Department of State Police FROM: CC: Mark E.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS EXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE HUMAN RESOURCES DIVISION ONE ASHBURTON PLACE, BOSTON, MA 02108 DEVAL L. PATRICK JAY GONZALEZ Governor Secretary TIMOTHY P. MURRAY Lieutenant Governor TEL.#: - FAX #: 617-727-3252 ER TO: Julayne Lazar Department of Revenue FROM: Mark E, D'Angelo, Director HRD/Office of Employee 617-727-3555 PAUL DIETL ~Chief Human Resources Officer CC: .

His name appeared on Certification No. 206437, which the states Human Resources Division (HRD) sent to the Fire Department on April 12, 2010. The Appellant signed the Certification indicating his willingness to accept appointment. For reasons unknown to the Commission at this time, the Fire Department made a second copy of the Certification and required candidates to sign both copies.

As part of the pre-hearing conference, relying on documentation provided by the BPD and the states Human Resources Division (HRD), the parties agreed that Mr. Alidrissis name appeared on Certification No.05194 and that he was tied in the 21st rank with other candidates, three of whom were appointed. Importantly, no candidate ranked below 21st was appointed from this Certification.