Third Associate City Solicitor City of Springfield 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 01103 May 24, 2022 SPR22/1105 Dear Attorney Roche: I have received the petition of Grace Ferguson of WBUR appealing the nonresponse of the Springfield Police Department (Department) to a request for public records. See G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1). On February 28, 2022, Ms.

To: Frazier-Shubrick, Marvenia Subject: RE: PRR #R005123-022822 Date: Friday, April 1, 2022 2:37:56 PM From: Springfield MA Public Records To: mfrazier-shubrick@springfieldcityhall.com Subject: [External] [GovQA] Requestor Communication - R005123022822 Date: Friday, April 1, 2022 12:12:24 PM From: Frazier-Shubrick, Marvenia To: "Kenney, Mark"; Bruno, J; Edward H. Geier; "Goodchild, Kara" Cc: Roche, Stephen G.

Roche Associate City Solicitor Law Department 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 01103 Direct Dial: (413) 787-6088 Fax: (413) 787-6173 Email: sroche@springfieldcityhall.com

Thank you, Chloe Meunier Collective Bargaining Agent Labor Relations City of Springfield 36 Court Street Springfield, MA 01103 P: (413) 784-4871 F: (413) 787-6572 CMeunier@springfieldcityhall.com

On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge Commissioner Claprood to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det. Bigdas reckless behavior has been a stain on our city for far too long and we demand closure. We call for immediate and swift justice. The fact that 6 years later, Bigda continues to receive a paycheck from the city of Springfield is a complete and utter disgrace.

On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge Commissioner Claprood to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det. Bigdas reckless behavior has been a stain on our city for far too long and we demand closure. We call for immediate and swift justice. The fact that 6 years later, Bigda continues to receive a paycheck from the city of Springfield is a complete and utter disgrace.

On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge Commissioner Claprood to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det. Bigdas reckless behavior has been a stain on our city for far too long and we demand closure. We call for immediate and swift justice. The fact that 6 years later, Bigda continues to receive a paycheck from the city of Springfield is a complete and utter disgrace.

Doug Hook; Editor; Jim Kinney; JohnBaibak@iheartmedia.com; Karen Brown WFCR; Matt; Michelle Williams; Mike Dobbs; New EnglandPublic Radio; Paul Tuthill (ptuth@wamc.org); Pete Goonan; Point of View; Republican; Western Mass News; Western Mass News 2; WWLP 22 Govan, Zaida; Mickiewicz, Kelley; Kacoyannakis, Susan For immediate press release Friday, February 11, 2022 11:12:41 AM Please see for immediate Press Release On behalf of the taxpayers of the City

Susan Kacoyannakis Administrative Aide Springfield City Council (413)787-6171 Press Release: On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge the Springfield Police Departments (SPD) Internal Investigations Unit as well as the citys Community Police Hearing Board to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det.

Susan Kacoyannakis Administrative Aide Springfield City Council (413)787-6171 Press Release: On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge the Springfield Police Departments (SPD) Internal Investigations Unit as well as the citys Community Police Hearing Board to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det.

Susan Kacoyannakis Administrative Aide Springfield City Council (413)787-6171 Press Release: On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge the Springfield Police Departments (SPD) Internal Investigations Unit as well as the citys Community Police Hearing Board to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgracedDetective Gregg Bigda. Det.

Susan Kacoyannakis Administrative Aide Springfield City Council (413)787-6171 Press Release: On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge the Springfield Police Departments (SPD) Internal Investigations Unit as well as the citys Community Police Hearing Board to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det.

Susan Kacoyannakis Administrative Aide Springfield City Council (413)787-6171 Press Release: On behalf of the taxpayers of the City of Springfield we strongly urge the Springfield Police Departments (SPD) Internal Investigations Unit as well as the citys Community Police Hearing Board to take immediate action and immediately dismiss disgraced-Detective Gregg Bigda. Det.

From: To: Subject: Date: Attachments: McCoy, Monique Martucci, Jeffery Bigda Thursday, December 16, 2021 8:40:20 AM charge letter.pdf Bigda charge letter Sergeant Monique McCoy Internal Investigation Unit Springfield Police Department 299 Page Boulevard Springfield, MA 01105 413-750-2235

Thank you, Sergeant Monique McCoy Internal Investigation Unit Springfield Police Department 299 Page Boulevard Springfield, MA 01105 413-750-2235

From: To: Subject: Date: McCoy, Monique Murphy, Lawrence FW: Bigda Thursday, February 17, 2022 9:48:46 AM From: McCoy, Monique Sent: Thursday, February 17, 2022 8:19 AM To: 'Maurice Cahillane' ; 'ldesousa@springfieldcityhall.com' Subject: Bigda Good Morning, Thank you, Sergeant Monique McCoy Internal Investigation Unit Springfield Police Department 299 Page Boulevard Springfield, MA 01105 413-750-

Thank you, Sergeant Monique McCoy Internal Investigation Unit Springfield Police Department 299 Page Boulevard Springfield, MA 01105 413-750-2235

Thank you, Sergeant Monique McCoy Internal Investigation Unit Springfield Police Department 299 Page Boulevard Springfield, MA 01105 413-750-2235

Beliveau Springfield Police Department Settlement Agreement Implementation Unit 299 Page Blvd Springfield, MA 01104 (413)787-6875

Beliveau Springfield Police Department Settlement Agreement Implementation Unit 299 Page Blvd Springfield, MA 01104 (413)787-6875

MASTROIANNI. 11 JURY SELECTION AND OPENINGS NOT TRANSCRIBED. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 APPEARANCES: On behalf of the government: Deepika Bains Shukla, Assistant United States Attorney, 300 State Street, Suite 230, Springfield, MA 01105. Christopher Perras, DOJ-Crt, 150 M Street, NE, 4con, Suite 7th Floor, Washington, DC 20002. On behalf of the defendant: Timothy R. Flaherty, 699 Boylston Street, 12th Floor, Boston, MA 02116.

Springfield, MA 01104 Main#: 413-787-6383 Fax#: 413-750-2236

Springfield, MA 01104 Main#: 413-787-6383 Fax#: 413-750-2236

MASTROIANNI 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 APPEARANCES: On behalf of the government: Deepika Bains Shukla, Assistant United States Attorney, 300 State Street, Suite 230, Springfield, MA 01105. Christopher Perras, DOJ-Crt, 150 M Street, NE, 4con, Suite 7th Floor, Washington, DC 20002. On behalf of the defendant: Timothy R. Flaherty, 699 Boylston Street, 12th Floor, Boston, MA 02116. Matthew D.

MASTROIANNI 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 APPEARANCES: On behalf of the government: Deepika Bains Shukla, Assistant United States Attorney, 300 State Street, Suite 230, Springfield, MA 01105. Christopher Perras, DOJ-Crt, 150 M Street, NE, 4con, Suite 7th Floor, Washington, DC 20002. On behalf of the defendant: Timothy R. Flaherty, 699 Boylston Street, 12th Floor, Boston, MA 02116. Matthew D.

MASTROIANNI. 11 JURY SELECTION AND OPENINGS NOT TRANSCRIBED. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 APPEARANCES: On behalf of the government: Deepika Bains Shukla, Assistant United States Attorney, 300 State Street, Suite 230, Springfield, MA 01105. Christopher Perras, DOJ-Crt, 150 M Street, NE, 4con, Suite 7th Floor, Washington, DC 20002. On behalf of the defendant: Timothy R. Flaherty, 699 Boylston Street, 12th Floor, Boston, MA 02116.

MASTROIANNI 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 APPEARANCES: On behalf of the government: Deepika Bains Shukla, Assistant United States Attorney, 300 State Street, Suite 230, Springfield, MA 01105. Christopher Perras, DOJ-Crt, 150 M Street, NE, 4con, Suite 7th Floor, Washington, DC 20002. On behalf of the defendant: Timothy R. Flaherty, 699 Boylston Street, 12th Floor, Boston, MA 02116. Matthew D.

Type of Record(s) Requested: Other Describe the Record(s) Requested: Hello, Pursuant to the Massachusetts Public Records Law, I hereby request the following records: I am seeking all responses (including any responsive documents and communications with the requester) provided by the City of Springfield in response to the public records request made by Sarah Ryley on 09/29/2022.

Ryley: I have received your letter appealing the response of the City of Springfield - Police Department to your request for records. I have directed a member of my staff, Jeffrey Gottfredsen, Esq., to review this matter. Upon completion of the review, I will advise you in writing of the disposition of this case. If in the interim you receive a satisfactory response to your request, please notify this office immediately.

Roche, Esq. 2nd Associate City Solicitor City of Springfield Law Department Public Records Division 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 01103 publicrecords@springfieldcityhall.com (413) 787-6085 SENT VIA EMAIL TO PRE@SEC.STATE.US December 12, 2022 Manza Arthur, Esq.

Ryley, I am emailing you to confirm that your public record request has been received and entered into the City of Springfield's GovQA Public Record Request Portal. This allows the City to better manage the many requests it receives. Your reference number is R006474-092922. I also would like to acknowledge that I have made note of your desire to be communicated with via email and outside of the portal.

Second Associate City Solicitor City of Springfield 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 01103 Dear Attorney Roche: I have received the petition of Sarah Ryley, of the Boston Globe, appealing the response of the City of Springfield (City) to a request for public records. G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1). On September 29, 2022, Ms.

EXHIBIT A Maryanne Stanganelli Fwd: Public Records Request :: R006329-090922 1 message Matt Drange To: Maryanne Stanganelli Thu, Dec 22, 2022 at 12:49 PM ---------- Forwarded message --------From: Matt Drange Date: Fri, Sep 9, 2022 at 9:22 AM Subject: Re: Public Records Request :: R006329-090922 To: Springfield MA Public Records

I understand the requestor has appealed to your office the response of the City of Springfield/Springfield Public Schools. This letter serves to inform you that the City of Springfield/Springfield Public Schools has revisited the request and its response. The City of Springfield/Springfield Public Schools is prepared to supplement its response to the public records request.

Drange submitted the following Request via the online portal for the City of Springfield: -All separation agreements and settlements reached with current and former teachers who taught in the district between January 1, 2017 through the day this request is fulfilled.

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND RELEASE This Settlement Agreement and Release (Agreement) is entered into by and among the Springfield Education Association (the Association), the City of Springfield acting by and through its Springfield Public Schools (SPS), and Ann Barone (Ms. Barone), a member of the bargaining unit represented by the Association. For valuable consideration given, SPS, the Association and Ms.

Kopec), the City of Springfield, acting by and through its Superintendent of the Springfield Public Schools (SPS) and the Springfield Education Association (SEA). employment at SPS. Mr. Kopec had made certain claims against SPS relating to his On or about November 22, 2013, a discrimination complaint was filed on behalf of Mr. Kopec with the Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination (MCAD), Docket No. 13SEM03159, entitled Cheryl A.

Subject RE: [External] FW: SPR23-0660 Appeal - City of Springfield Response To "Durgin, Barbara (SEC)" , "mstanaganelli@insider.com" Date April 13, 2023 at 4:46:37 PM GMT Dear Attorney Durgin, Please see the Citys response to this Appeal. Note that we will be producing records by April 28, 2023. Please note the requestor has been copied on this email.

Drange submitted the following Request via the online portal for the City of Springfield: -All separation agreements and settlements reached with current and former teachers who taught in the district between January 1, 2017 through the day this request is fulfilled.

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND RELEASE This Scttlement Agreement and Release (Agreement) is entered into by and among the Springfield Education Association (the Association"), the City of Springfield acting by and through its Springfield Public Schools (SPS), and Courtney Lombardi (Ms. Lombardi), a member of the bargaining unit represented by the Association and is effective on the date of the last signature of this Agreement (Effective Date).

Roche, Esq. 2nd Associate City Solicitor City of Springfield 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 0103 Dear Attorney Roche: I have received the petition of Attorney Maryanne Stanganelli, of Insider Inc., appealing the response of the Springfield Public Schools (School) to a request for public records. G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1).

Springfield Public schools WAC Springfield Education Association _ ATTACHMENT A REDACTED ,Af/1.] w ~ch,_J 2018 Dan Warwick, Superintendent Springfield Public Schools 1550 Main Street Springfield, MA 01103 Dear Dr. Warwick, Please accept my resignation from Springfield Public Schools, effective immediately. Thank you.

(Association), and the City of Springfield, acting by and through its Springfield Public Schools (SPS) (collectively the Parties), and is effective on the Effective Date of this Agreement. WHEREAS, Ms. Rodd had made certain claims against SPS relating to her employment at SPS which ended in her retirement in October 2016. WHEREAS, on or about December 23, 2016, Ms.

(Association), and the City of Springfield, acting by and through its Springfield Public Schools (SPS) (collectively the Parties), and is effective on the Effective Date of this Agreement. WHEREAS, Ms. Eustace had made certain claims against SPS relating to her employment at SPS which ended in her termination of employment on August 30, 2016. WHEREAS, on September 14, 2016, Ms.

Drange submitted the following Request via the online portal for the City of Springfield: -All separation agreements and settlements reached with current and former teachers who taught in the district between January 1, 2017 through the day this request is fulfilled.

my spouse, executors, 1 REDACTE administrators, estates, assigns, officers, directors, shareholders, employees, agents, attorneys, subsidiaries and divisions, predecessors and successors in interest (hereinafter: collectively referred toas Reteasor}, in consideration of the terms outlined in the within Settlement Agreement, and othergood and valuable consideration, hereby release, acquit and forever discharge the Springfield School Committee, the City

Phelps Legal Counsel Office of Legal Services Springfield Public Schools 1550 Main Street 2nd Floor Springfield, MA 01103 Phone: (413) 787-7100, Ext. 55325 Fax: (413) 787-7171 phelpsm@springfieldpublicschools.com CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Box 1410 Springfield, MA 01103-1410 413-787-7100 x 55325 phelpsm@springfieldpublicschools.com SPRINGFIELD PUBLIC SCHOOLS - SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS April 28, 2023 VIA EMAIL ONLY Attorney Maryanne Stanganelli mstanganelli@insider.com One Liberty Plaza 8th FL New York, NY 10006 Re: Appeal of Springfield Public Schools Response to Request for Records Associated with Employee Separation Agreements SPR22/2943 and SPR23/0660 Dear Ms.

Box 1410 Springfield, MA 01103-1410 Dear Attorney Phelps: I have received the petition of Attorney Maryanne Stanganelli, of /nsider Inc., appealing the response of the Springfield Public Schools (School) to a request for public records. G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1).

Box 1410 Springfield, MA 01103-1410 413-787-7100 x 55325 phelpsm@springfieldpublicschools.com SPRINGFIELD PUBLIC SCHOOLS - SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS April 13, 2023 VIA EMAIL ONLY Barbara Durgin, Esquire Barbara.Durgin@sec.state.ma.us Senior Attorney Office of the Secretary of the Commonwealth Public Records Division One Ashburton Place, Room 1719 Boston, MA 02108 Dear Ms.

Box 1410 Springfield, MA 01103-1410 413-787-7100 x 55325 phelpsm@springfieldpublicschools.com SPRINGFIELD PUBLIC SCHOOLS - SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS April 13, 2023 VIA EMAIL ONLY Barbara Durgin, Esquire Barbara.Durgin@sec.state.ma.us Senior Attorney Office of the Secretary of the Commonwealth Public Records Division One Ashburton Place, Room 1719 Boston, MA 02108 Dear Ms.

Box 1410 Springfield, MA 01103-1410 413-787-7100 x 55325 phelpsm@springfieldpublicschools.com September 30, 2022 mdrange@insider.com Mr. Matt Drange Business Insider 535 Mission Street, 14th Floor San Francisco, CA 94105 RE: Public Records Request to Springfield Public Schools Dear Mr. Drange: The Springfield Public Schools received your public records request by email on September 1, 2021. The response was due on September 16th.

Box 1410 Springfield, MA 01103-1410 413-787-7100 x 55325 phelpsm@springfieldpublicschools.com SPRINGFIELD PUBLIC SCHOOLS - SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS January 19, 2023 Attorney Maryanne Stanganelli One Liberty Plaza 8th FL New York, NY 10006 Re: Appeal of Springfield Public Schools Response to Request for Records Associated with Employee Separation Agreements and Sexual Misconduct Claims SPR22/2943 Dear Ms.

Rule 29: SECTION 1: All members of the Department shall obey the Rules and Regulations as set forth herein, the Ordinances of the City of Springfield, the laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and of the United States of America, and shall perform their duties with silent courage, discretion, placing the safety and welfare of the City of Springfield and its citizens first at all times. Rule 29: SECTION 4.

Box 308 Springfield, MA 01101 (413) 787-6313 THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS Mr. L O July 25, 2016 SO# 16-049 Dear Mr. O In regard to the complaint you filed on March 25, 2016, please be advised that the subsequent investigation and reports were reviewed. In order for you to understand our internal investigation process I should give you some background.

Morin Paralegal City of Springfield Law Department 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 01103 Main: (413) 787-6085 Direct: (413) 787-6550 Fax: (413) 787-6173 Email: jmorin@springfieldcityhall.com

DEPARTMENTAL AND INTER-DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE City of Springfield I DATE: 5-12-21 PO: 21-246 TO: ALL COMMANDING OFFICERS CC: DEPUTY CHIEF WILLIAM COCHRANE DF,:PUTY CHIEF STEVEN KENT DEPUTY CHIEF RUPERT DANIEL SENIOR CAPTAIN TRENT DUDA LYNN VEDOVELLI/PAYROLL/TELESTAFF LISA WILLIS SUBJECT: RESIGNATION - OFFICER JOSHUA FIGUEROA Effective the close of business today, Wednesday, May 12, 2021, Officer Joshua Figueroa will resign his position as a Police

Third Associate City Solicitor City of Springfield 36 Court Street Springfield, MA 01103 Dear Attorney Roche: I have received the petition of Daniel Jaffe, of the CPCS Strategic Litigation Unit, appealing the response of the City of Springfield (City) to a request for public records. G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1). On December 9, 2021, Mr. Jaffe requested the following records for an identified officer: a.

Third Associate City Solicitor City of Springfield 36 Court Street Springfield, MA 01103 Dear Attorney Roche: I have received the petition of Daniel Jaffe, of the CPCS Strategic Litigation Unit, appealing the response of the City of Springfield (City) to a request for public records. G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1). On December 9, 2021, Mr. Jaffe requested the following records for an identified officer: a.

DEPARTMENTAL AND INTER-DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE City of Springfield PO: 19-293 TO: CAPTAIN RUPERT DANIEL CC: DEPUTY CHIEF WILLIAM COCHRANE DEPUTY CHIEF STEVEN KENT LYNN VEDOVELLI/PAYROLL/TELESTAFF LISA WILLIS SUBJECT: DATE: 6-26-19 | RETURN TO FULL DUTY- OFFICER JOSHUA FIGUEROA Effective Sunday, June 30, 2019, Officer Joshua Figueroa will teturn to full duty on Squad B Uniform Division reporting to Captain Rupert Daniel for assignment, Cheryl C

Maam | realize how much of a blessing and how fortunate being a police officer in the city of Springfield is.

Michael K Attorney for the Commonwealth Dana Parsons Hampden County District Attorney Prosecutor Hampden County District Attorney Hail of Justice 50 State Street, 3rd fir Hampden County District Attorney Springfield, MA 01103 50 State St springfield, MA 01103 Work Phone (413) 747-1000 Added Date: 02/27/2019 Defendant Private Counsel Raipher D Pellegrino Raipher PC Figueroa, Joshua 667684 560614 Raipher PC 265 State St Springfield, MA 01103 Work Phone

On May 11, 2016 I interviewed Ms C R Caron Management, Kimball Towers Condominiums, 140 Chestnut Street, Springfield MA, 413-732-2766. Ms R stated that around 3:15 PM she observed an unidentified White male (from this point forward the unidentified White male will be referred to as Mr. John Smith), who was not then or ever a resident of 140 Chestnut Street, standing outside of 140 Chestnut Street via the security camera system.

R008782-081923 - Public Records Request Message History (8) On 9/19/2023 12:27:00 PM, Springfield MA Public Records wrote: Subject: [Records Center] Public Records Request :: R008782-081923 Body: RE: PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST of August 19, 2023, Reference #R008782-081923 Dear Nathaniel Story, This email is in response to your public records request to the City of Springfield for Hello, Pursuant to the Massachusetts Public Records Law, I hereby request

RE: PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST of January 12, 2023, Reference #R007175-011223 Dear Jennifer Cava-Foreman, Esq., This email is in response to your public records request to the City of Springfield for: Any internal investigation reports related to Springfield Police Officers who arrested of S C DOB at Springfield, MA on 03/30/2020 for charges filed under docket number (Springfield PD v. S C for charges 1.

Box 308 Springfield MA 01101 (413) 787-6300 July 23, 2021 VIA HAND DELIVERY Officer Samantar Muse Springfield Police Department 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 | Re: | Notice of Inter-Departmental Disciplinary Charges, SO#21-066 | Dear Officer Muse: Please be advised that the Springfield Police Department has received information regarding your on duty vehicle collision on May 2, 2021.

Box 308 Springfield,MA 01101 (413) 787-6313 = im wacal Som i.fh. | afi TT ) ds,sac: = hanno.

Box 308 Springfield MA 01101 (413) 787-6300 October 7, 2021 VIA HAND DELIVERY Officer Samantar Muse Springfield Police Department 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 Re: Notice of Suspension Without Pay, SO#21-066 Dear Samantar Muse: You are hereby advised that as the Police Commissioner of the Springfield Police Department (SPD), I am suspending you without pay for Fifteen (15) working days for your actions and/or omissions on May 2, 2021 when

Box 308 Springfield MA 01101 (413) 787-6300 October 21, 2021 VIA HAND DELIVERY Officer Samantar Muse Springfield Police Department 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 Re: Notice of Suspension Without Pay, SO#2 1-066 Dear Samantar Muse: You are hereby advised that as the Police Commissioner of the Springfield Police Department (SPD), I am suspending you without pay for Fifteen (15) working days for your actions and/or omissions on May 2, 2021 when

Morin Public Records Coordinator/Paralegal City of Springfield Law Department 36 Court Street, Room 210 Springfield, MA 01103 Main: (413) 787-6085 Direct: (413) 787-6550 Fax: (413) 787-6173

Box 308 Springfield MA 01101 (413) 787-6300 July 9, 2021 VIA HAND DELIVERY Officer Samantar Muse Springfield Police Department 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 Re: Notice of Suspension Without Pay, SO#21-066 Deat Samantar Muse; You are hereby advised that as the Police Commissioner of the Springfield Police Department (SPD), I am suspending you without pay for One (1) working day for your actions and/or omissions on or about June 21 and June

Box 308 Springfield MA 01101 | (413) 787-6300 June 25, 2021 VIA HAND DELIVERY Officer Samantar Muse Springfield Police Department 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 Re: Notice of Suspension Without Pay, SO#21-066 Dear Samantar Muse: You are hereby advised that as the Police Commissioner of the Springfield Police Department (SPD), I am suspending you without pay for One (1) working day for your actions and/or omissions on or about June 21 and June

Box 308 Springfield, MA 01101 (413) 787-6313 THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS July 5, 2018 D R Street Springfield, MA 01107 Re: Citizen's Complaint 18-30 Dear Mr. R Please contact the Internal Investigation Unit of the Springfield Police Department, 130 Maple Street, as soon as possible relative to your complaint of July 2, 2018, so that further inquiry can be assured. The phone number to the Internal Investigation Unit is 787-6383.

. | Springfield, MA 01101 (413) 787-6313 4 im ~ ab pode coo ii.) i Dis," 1 | 2%. re aeaiieyena ; war eho ge al he THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS October 6, 2021 On September 8, 2021 an administrative hearing involving Officer Samantar Muse was held regarding his actions on May 2, 2021. The hearing was in regards to Special Order 21-066 and the resulting Internal Investigation.

Box 308 Pave Springfield, MA O1101 Alii WH (413) 787-6313 een Hdl = I i LE... THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS January 10, 2022 M Street Palmer, MA 01069 In regard to the complaint you filed on November 13, 2021 (SO#21-139); please be advised that the subsequent investigation and reports were reviewed. In order for you to understand our internal investigation process I should give you some background.

Box 308 Springfield, MA 01101 (413) 787-6313 go ae es 4 ar. Ph 99 Bel 3 = ae ye ee . ace | : - Sa otacaiae AXE er aT 7 5 fy os Th. & _ ore. anes PE, THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS October 23, 2018 Mr. , in | Street Springfield, Massachusetts 01107 In regard to the complaint you filed on July 2, 2018, please be advised that the subsequent investigation and reports were reviewed.

System Code MedicalFacilily See Above MUSE SAMANTAR M 130PEARLST SPRINGFIELD, MA 01105-1018 M 1 1 4 0 0 4 1 ORllZALEX 130PEARLST SPRINGFIELD, MA 01105 M 3 1 4 0 0 4 2 PW201803700644 BAYSTATE MEDICAL (SPRINGFI ELD) Page l of 4 Please Select One of the 1 Vehicle # Occupants License# Sex M - - Lie. Oass Operator D Type Location 1998 VehYear 1 Endorsement MA 01104-2724 SPRINGFIELD Clty ZIP----- Responding to Emergency ?

Box 308 Springfield , MA 01101 (413) 787-6313 THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS November 16, 2021 M R Street Palmer, MA 01069 Dear M R Please contact the Internal Investigation Unit of the Springfield Police Department, 299 Page Boulevard, as soon as possible regarding your complaint received on November 13, 2021. The phone number to the Internal Investigation Unit is 787-6383.

Respectfully submitted, ~t~~oyMl~ 'DEPARTMENTAL AND INTER-DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE City of Springfield I DATE: 4-15-2020 SO: 20-049 TO: CAPTAIN LAWRENCE MURPHY CC: DEPUTY CHIEF WILLIAM COCHRANE DEPUTY CHIEF STEVEN KENT DEPUTY CHIEF RUPERT DANIEL SENIOR CAPTAIN TRENT DUDA SUBJECT: INVESTIGATION INTO THE INCIDENT RELATED TO REPORT #20-3753-OF.

Rule 29 Section 1: Sustained All members of the Department shall obey the Rules and regulations as set forth herein, the Ordinances of the City of Springfield, the Laws of the Commonwealth Massachusetts and of the United States of America, and shall perform their duties with silent courage, discretion, placing the safety and welfare of the City of Springfield and its citizens first at all times.

. * Kequletbans City of Springfield Community Police Hearing Board Case Review PIE#20-020 Citizen's Complaint#27 Where did this complaint originate? Police Department: Date complaint was filed? 9/28/2020 What is the date of the CPHB Citizen: X Date IU completed its investigation? 12/1/2020 review? Is this case recommended to be sent back to I[U?

Clapprood Acting Police Commissioner TH2 22 Land CoC peg Acting Commissioner Cheryl Clapprood: Da ne G@ Ne / / q oe OW FouAsD aD) City of Springfield Community Police Hearing Board Case Review PIE# 19-008 Citizen's Complaint# 12 Where did this complaint originate? Police Department: Date complaint was filed? 3/18/19 What is the date of the CPHB Citizen: X Date HU completed its investigation? 6/4/19 review?

Clapprood: Allen Lhe_ Cem Nerve), pla int As Lo Jor Date: Z/ ot aL Er GAG ate Mor SUSTAINEL oo Sustaiwe be Lt Jatt Ly \ City of Springfield Community Police Hearing Board Case Review SO#/PIE# SO#21-139 Citizen's Complaint: __ Where did this complaint originate? | CPHB: #21-030 Police Department: Citizen: XX XX Date complaint was filed? 11-13-2021 Date IU completed its investigation? 12-16-2021 What is the date of the CPHB review?

Swutawl ee Clune ves\ | | City of Springfield Community Police Hearing Board Case Review SO#/18-161 Citizen's Complaint: Where did this complaint originate? | CPHB: Date complaint was filed? _7-2-18 _ xxxx Police Department: Citizen: xxx Date HU completed its investigation? 9-22-18 What is the date of the CPHB review? i 09-25 -18 Is this case recommended to be sent back to HU?

Box 308 Springfield MA 01101 (413) 787-6300 August 26, 2021 VIA HAND DELIVERY Officer Samantar Muse 130 Pearl Street Springfield MA 01105 Re: Notice of Hearing, SO#21-066 Dear Officer Muse: In accordance with Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 31, the Springfield Police Department will hold a hearing on September 8, 2021 at 10:00 am in the Police Commissioners Room 130 Pearl Street, Springfield MA. to contemplate the issuance of discipline, up to

Springfield Police Department shBFS83x fe {2 eS ze 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 23 November 2022 Special to Captain David Kane Re: EVOC re-training (Officer S. Muse) Sir, On 23 November 2022 I, Officer Anthony T. Kelliher, conducted re-training of Officer S. Muse at the Springfield Police Academy.

This was on school street Springfield ma at 12:30. The cop did not give his name when I asked . Something needs to be done Were there witnesses? Yes If yes, please list their name, address, and telephone number: J f Testify? Yes, I am willing to testify. 1 SPRINGFIELD POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL REPORT FORM DATE: 09/07/2022 Format: MM/DD/YYYY Type of Report (Specify): Special to Sup. C.

WESTFIELD, MA Age: 33 Charges: STOP FOR POLICE, FAIL LICENSE SUSPENDED, OP MV WITH Page: 2 Springfield Police Department Citation Listing 05/11/2019 CITATION#: Tl640202 CALL#: INCIDENT#: ARREST#: ACCIDENT#: ISSUED IN HAND 03/01/2019 1815 BY Officer Joshua Beliveau TYPE: Warning TO OPERATOR: ST, WESTFIELD, MA 01085 (MALE) SSN: DOB: LICENSE: OWNER: -- VEHICLE: BLK SE 1991 TOYT COROLLA REG: NC PLATE: PC OFFENSE(S) ON 03/01/2019@ 1423 BOSTON RD @PARKER ST, SPRINGFIELD

McKinnon Cc: "Tirado, Marta" , "'Stair, Joshua (SEC)'" , "Frazier-Shubrick, Marvenia" , "Oyola, Gladys" Subject: RE: [External] FW: Compliance Inquiry for SPR21/1998 McKinnon/Springfield Police Department Dear Attorney McKinnon, I apologize for the delay in responding to you on behalf of the City

SEVERAL TRE SvTIRE ConfisntT poor Eo VvE s ee . dd cw) aS wry / CPT MD City of Springfield Community Police Hearing Board Case Review SO/PIE# 17-134 Citizen's Complaint # N/A Where did this complaint originate? (Circle one) CPHB (ice Depa Other: Date complaint was filed? 7/2/17 What was the date I[U completed its investigation? What is the date of the CPHB review? _ 8/22/17 \ ENS V7 Is this case recommended to be sent back to ITU?

Stone Springfield Police Department 130 Pearl Street Springfield, MA 01105 Dear Ms. Stone: I have received the petition of Ms. Jennifer McKinnon appealing the nonresponse of the Springfield Police Department (Department) to a request for public records. G. L. c. 66, 10A; see also 950 C.M.R. 32.08(1). Specifically, Ms. McKinnon requested copies of an identified internal affair files. Having received no response, she petitioned this office.

Addresst: Springfield MA Prev.