Legends Way 149 Charles St 967 Commonwealth Avenue 161 Brighton Ave 45 Union St 292 Hanover Street 100 Legends Way 58 Seaport Blvd Suite 200 115 Beverly St 50 Dalton St 209 Columbus Ave 246 Tremont Street 60 Seaport Blvd 58 SEAPORT BLVD 3 Lansdowne Street 1 Nashua Street 290 Shore Road 260 Shrewsbury Street 121 Grandview Road 250B Granite Street 170 Forbes Rd Brewster 596 Washington Street 967 Commonwealth Ave 400 District black & blue steak and crab, Burlington

MA 02215 4 Yawkey Way Boston, MA 02215 4 YAWKEY WAY BOSTON, MA 02215 Boston, Massachusetts 171 Milk Street 02109 Bourne, Massachusetts 57 Main Street 02532 39 Broad Bridgewater, MA 02324 Street 338 Washington Brighton, MA 02135 Street 235 E Ashland Brockton MA 02302 Street 500 West Gate Brockton, MA 02301 Drive 265 Samuel Brockton, Ma 02301 Avenue 265 North Pearl Brockton, Ma 02301 Street 235 East Brockton, Ma 02302 Ashland Street 17 3rd Street Burlington

MUP-10-6020, *6 (CERB 2014);1City of Cambridge, 5 MLC 1291 (1978); Town of Burlington, 6 MLC 1795 (H.O. 1980). The futility of the Unions efforts to negotiate in good faith with the Employer are further illustrated by the Employers bargaining tactics during the single post-vote negotiations session on outsourcing therapy services held by the parties two weeks after the May 18 vote.

Dwyer and Duddy 25 Burlington Mall Road, Suite 411 Burlington, MA 01803 Scott W. Dunlap, Esq. 89 Assess Road, Suite 19 Norwood, MA 02062 Re: MUP-16-5441/MUP-16-5438, City of Boston Dear Mr. Costello, Mr. Dwyer, and Mr.

McKenna 7 Bedford Street, Unit A Burlington, MA 01803 (781) 425-7867 emckenna@afscme93.org

See Town of Burlington v. Labor Relations Commission, 17 Mass. App. Ct. 402 (1984) (not promoting a deputy chief to the temporary management position of acting chief was an adverse action). Animus A charging party may proffer direct or indirect evidence of discrimination in support of its claim. See Town of Brookfield, 28 MLC 320, 327-328, MUP-2538 (May 1, 2002), aff'd sub nom, Town of Brookfield v.

Dwyer, BBO #139840 Dwyer, Duddy and Esposito Attorneys at Law, P.C. 25 Burlington Mall Road, Suite 411 Burlington, MA 01803 781-359-9777 Date: __ Gogo, 26 (/ 2016 F:\BASAS\SESSReorganization2015\MUP- 15-463 l\pldg\noticevoluntarylwithdrawal.docx CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true copy of the foregoing document was served upon: Joseph Bevington, IV Labor Counsel Boston Public Schools Bolling Municipal Building 2300 Washington Street

Fax Number S.411, Burlington, MA 01803 781-272-8692 11. This charge is filed against (check one) 72.

Esposito, BBO # 672638 Dwyer, Duddy and Esposito Attorneys at Law, PC 25 Burlington Mall Road, Suite 411 Burlington, MA (781) 359-9777 Date: August 16, 2013 01803 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE A true copy of the foregoing document has been served upon: Ann Chan Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources Boston Public Schools 26 Court Street Boston, MA 02108 via first-class mail, postage prepaid, this 16" day of August, 2013.

Telephone Number Sean Lafferty (781) 270-5000 Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) 8. 15 New England Executive Park, Burlington, MA 5. Fax Number 01803 10. Fax Number (781) 270-4447 11. This charge is filed against (check one) 12.

Town of Burlington, 35 MLC 18, 25, MUP-04-4157 Burlington v. Commonwealth Employment (June 30, 2008), affd sub nom., Town Relations Board, 85 Mass. App. of Ct. 1120 1, 5, SUP-4304 (June 30, (May 19, 2014); Commonwealth of Massachusetts, 27 MLC 2000).

Town of Burlington, 35 MLC 18, 25, MUP-04-4157 Burlington v. Commonwealth Employment (May 19, 2014); Commonwealth (June 30, 2008), affd sub nom., Town Relations Board, 85 Mass. App. of Massachusetts, 27 MLC 1, 5, SUP-4304 of Ct. 1120 (June 30, 2000). To establish a unilateral change violation, the charging party must show that: 1) the employer altered an existing practice or instituted a new one; 2) the change affected H.O. Decision (cont.)

CERB Review of PC Dismissal (cont'd) MUPL-14-3993 and conditions of employment and are, therefore, mandatory subjects of bargaining. see Town of Burlington, 35 MLC 18, 25, MUP-04-4157, (June 30, 2008), affd sub nom. Town of Burlington v. CERB, 85 Mass. App. Ct. 1120 (2014); Town of Winthrop, 20 MLC 200 (and cases cited therein).

(January 4, 2002); Town See Town of Burlington, of Winthrop, 35 MLC 28 MLC 18, 24-25, 200, 202, MUP-04-4157, 2008), aff'd sub nom. Town of Burlington v. CERB, 85 Mass. App. Ct. MUP-2288 (June 30, 1120 (2014)(Rule 19 1:28 decision).