COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE M.G.L. c. 150E INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions. Do NOT _|C28 N BateFiled kL UAO-1G D1e3, IAAT AF Failing to provide information may resull in the dismissal of the charge.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS ________________________________________________ ) MASSACHUSETTS NURSES ASSOCIATION ) Charging Party, ) ) v. ) ) COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, ) SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND ) FINANCE/DEPARTMENT OF MENTAL HEALTH ) Respondent. ) ________________________________________________ ) SUP-19-7163 RESPONDENTS RESPONSE TO CHARGING PARTYS PETITION FOR CERB REVIEW On or about February 15, 2019,

Thomson: AFSCME, Council 93 (Union) appeals from a Department of Labor Relations (DLR) Investigators dismissal of the above-referenced charge of prohibited practice.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE M.G.L. .150E INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS 19 STANIFORD STREET, 1" FLOOR BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS 02114 Telephone: FAX: (617) 626-7132 (617) 626-7157 www.mass.gov/dir DEVAL L. PATRICK GOVERNOR TIMOTHY P. MURRAY COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD MARJORIE F. WITTNER LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR CHAIR ERICA F. CRYSTAL ELIZABETH NEUMEIER DIRECTOR BOARD MEMBER HARRIS FREEMAN BoaRD MEMBER October 31, 2012 Jack J. Canzoneri, Esq.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS RAKKKRKKKEEEEEREREREERERREEEEKEREEREKERERERERERERRERERREKE In the Matter of * CITY OF BOSTON * and * * * PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION Case No.: MUP-15-4572 Date Issued: March 18, 2016 * RREKRREREEEREEEEKEKEEKEKEREEREREREEREEKEREEREEREEREREEKKE AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE On May 15, 2015, the Professional Staff Association ON REMAND (PSA or Union) filed a charge of prohibited

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS ) DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matter of: ) ) BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY ) Complainant, ) and ) ) Before Hearing Officer CITY OF BOSTON, ) Margaret Sullivan Respondent, ) d PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION, ad ) : wd = p Case No.: MUP-I5-4 ) ) and ) AFSCME, AFL-CIO, COUNCIL 93, ) ) ) Intervenor. ) COMPLAINANTS ASSENTED-TO MOTION TO EXTEND APPEAL TIMELINE Complainant

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD REKKEEKKEEREKRKEEKERKEEKEKEKEKERERREREREER FF SF In the Matter of Case No. MUP-15-4572 HB FH CITY OF BOSTON Date Issued: July 15, 2016 BF . + + AFSCME COUNCIL 93, AFL-CIO + and * FF PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION F&F HB F and RRKAKKREEEEERREREEEEREEEEERRERRERRERERERE CERB Members Participating: Marjorie F.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS + KRKKEKRREEREKREKKKRKEKEEREEKEREKKEEREERERERER In the Matter of * CITY OF BOSTON * Case No. MUP-15-4572 and * Date Issued: May 20, 2019 PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION and * * * AFSCME COUNCIL 93, AFL-CIO * * Hearing Officer: Margaret M. Sullivan, Esq. Appearances: Robert J.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS F&F SF In the Matter of Case No. MUP-15-4572 &H F&F CITY OF BOSTON Date Issued: May 2, 2016 F &F and FF & PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION & and + + AFSCME COUNCIL 93, AFL-CIO HAEKREEKKHEEERERERRRERRERERERERREEERERREE Hearing Officer: Margaret M. Sullivan, Esq. Appearances: Jessica L. Dembro, Esq. - Representing the City of Boston Nicole Horberg Decter, Esq.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matter of: Professional Staff Association, Complainant and MUP-15-4572 The Boston Public Library, Respondent RESPONDENTS RESPONSE TO COMPLAINANTS APPEAL OF THE DEPARMENTS PARTIAL DISMISSAL L INTRODUCTION On May 15, 2015, the Professional Staff Association (the Union or PSA) filed a charge of prohibited practice with the Department of Labor Relations (DLR),

PSA (Professional Staff Association) Charging Party, And CITY OF BOSTON, Boston Public Library Respondent. eNOS NS SS SS SS COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHSUETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS MUP 15-4572 RESPONDENTS RESPONSE TO CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE The City denies the allegations. The City has not violated Section 10(a)(1) and 10(a)(5). Respectfully submitted, The Respondent, City of Boston, By its Attorney, Jessica L. Dembro, Esq.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARLES F. HURLEY 19 STANIFORD CHARLES D. BAKER BUILDING STREET COMMONWEALTH PHONE: (617) 626-7132 RELATIONS BOARD 18" FLoor, BOSTON, MA 02114 EMPLOYMENT GOVERNOR FAX: (617) 626-7157 MARUJORIE F. WITTNER KARYN E. POLITo efile.dIr@state.ma.us www.mass.gov/dlr El LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR CHaIR Ben AEENEES KATHERINE G. LEV BOARD MEMBER April 12, 2016 Nicole H. Decter, Esq.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARLES F. HURLEY BUILDING 19 STANIFORD STREET 1sT FLOOR, BOSTON, MA 02114 CHARLES D. BAKER COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT PHONE: (617) 626-7132 RELATIONS BOARD GOVERNOR Fax: (617) 626-7157 MARJORIE F. WITTNER KARYN E. POLITO efile.dir@state.ma.us LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR CHAIR www.mass.gov/dir ELIZABETH NEUMEIER BOARD MEMBER KATHERINE G. LEV BOARD MEMBER March 18, 2016 Nicole H. Decter, Esq.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE M.G.L. .150E INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions. Note: Pursuant to 456 CMR DO NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE Case No.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD F KAKA KKKEKHREEKAEKEERKEEKEREREEEAEEKEREEERER HF HF In the Matter of Case No. MUP-15-4572 HF HB CITY OF BOSTON Date Issued: April 26, 2019 FF PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION F F F and + intervenor + AFSCME COUNCIL 93, AFL-CIO, + & FF and fTrrrrrrrrrr er rere re rer Te PP CERB Members Participating: Marjorie F.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matter of CITY OF BOSTON, Respondent Case No. MUP-15-4572 and PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION, Complainant and AFSCME COUNCIL 93, AFL-CIO, Intervenor INTERVENORS POST-HEARING BRIEF I.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION, Charging Party v. THE CITY OF BOSTON/BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY Respondent And MUP-15-4572 AFSCME, Council 93, Intervener CITY OF BOSTONS POST-HEARING BRIEF Respectfully submitted, THE CITY OF BOSTON, BY: 1 Robert Boyle, Esq.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY PROFESSIONAL STAFF ASSOCIATION, Complainant, v.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DIVISION OF LABOR RELATIONS HINGHAM EDUCATION ASSOCIATION, Charging Party v, HINGHAM SCHOOL COMMITTEE, Respondent ) ) ) ) ) ) MUP-19-7744 ) ) RESPONDENT, HINGHAM SCHOOL COMMITTEE'S ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE Now comes the Respondent, Hingham School Committee ("Hingham"), in response to the Department of Labor Relations issuance of a Complaint of Prohibited Practice ("Complaint") in the above-referenced

fCOMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS __________________________________________ ) HINGHAM EDUCATION ASSOCIATION, ) Charging Party, ) ) and ) ) HINGHAM SCHOOL COMMITTEE, ) Respondent. ) ) __________________________________________) MUP-19-7744 CHARGING PARTY, HINGHAM EDUCATION ASSOCITIONS NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM PARTIAL DISMISSAL AND SUPPORTING STATEMENT The Charging Party, Hingham Education Association (HEA), hereby appeals from

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE M.G.L. c.150E DO NOT WRITE Case No. . MY~-194-F 744 | IN THIS SPACE Date Filed A-13 14 + . INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions. Failing to provide information may result in the dismissal of the charge.

Waugh: The Hingham Education Association (Union) appeals from a Department of Labor Relations (DLR) Investigators partial dismissal of the above-referenced charge of prohibited practice. After reviewing the investigation record, the partial dismissal and the arguments on review, the Commonwealth Employment Relations Board (CERB) remands this aspect of the charge to the Investigator to amend the complaint in a manner consistent with this ruling.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSEnS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE M.G.L. c.150E Amended charge nn /\LOT: JIIITHI!': !':PAr.1= Case No. Date Filed MUP-19-7744 INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions. Failing to provide information may result in the dismissal of the charge.

THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARLES F. HURLEY BUILDING 19 STANIFORD STREET CHARLES 0. BAKER GOVERNOR COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD 1ST FLOOR, BOSTON, MA 02114 PHONE: (617) 626-7132 FAX: (617) 626-7157 MARJORIE F. WITTNER efile.dlr@state.ma.us www.mass.gov/dlr ELIZABETH NEUMEIER KARYN E. POLITO LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR CHAIR BOARD MEMBER KATHERINE G. LEV BOARD MEMBER August 19, 2016 Kristen Barnes, Esq.

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matter of Framingham Police Officers Union, Charging Party CASE NO.: MIJP-16-5088 & Town of Framingham, Respondent TOWNS RESPONSE TO FPOUS PROHIBITED PRACTICE CHARGE The Town of Framingham (hereinafter the Town) hereby respectfully submits this response to the Charging Partys (herein after the Union or FPOUs) allegation that the Town violated ~ 10(a)(1) and 1O(a)(5) of the Law when the Town refused to produce confidential

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS fae his motion is: S-s, Marlborough Municipal Employees 5F DEPARTMENT OF Weert Caucowed > DLR Agent p Tis - MUP-18-6822 a Charging Party Respondent CHARGING PARTY'S ASSENTED-TO MOTION TO CONTINUE IN-PERSON INVESTIGATION SN a City of Marlborough, NOW COMES the Charging Party (MMEA) and respectfully moves to continue the In-Person Investigation in the above-captioned

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS Marlborough Municipal Employees Association, Charging Party and City of Marlborough, Respondent ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) MUP-18-6822 MUP-19-7061 RESPONDENT, CITY OF MARLBOROUGHS, POST HEARING BRIEF This case boils down to two separate allegations that the City of Marlborough (the City) somehow violated General Laws Chapter 150E (the Law) when, in one instance, the Citys Human Resources Director

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS *************************************** * In the Matter of * * CITY OF MARLBOROUGH * * and * * MARLBOROUGH MUNICPAL * EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION * * **************************************** Case Nos. MUP-18-6822 MUP-19-7061 Date Issued: November 3, 2020 Hearing Officer: Margaret M. Sullivan, Esq.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DO NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE Case No. M.G.L. c.150E INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions. Date Filed MUPR{ Dr2te P-of1F F Failing to provide information may result in the dismissal of the charge.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BEFORE THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS Marlborough Municipal Employees Association, Charging Party and City of Marlborough, Respondent ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) MUP-18-6822 MUP-19-7061 CHARGING PARTYS POST-HEARING BRIEF I.

Roberts, Director Department of Labor Relations 19 Staniford Street, 1' Floor Boston, MA Re: 02114 Chelmsford Federation of Teachers AFT Chelmsford School Committee Case No.: MUP-17-6374 Local 3569 vy. Dear Mr. Roberts: Enclosed is Respondent Chelmsford School Committees Response to Notice of Appeal in the above referenced matter. Should you need any additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me. hej Very truly yours, Andrew J.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD REEKKKEKEKERKREREERERREREREREREREERERREREREEERERERRERER In the Matter of * CHELMSFORD SCHOOL COMMITTEE * Case No. and * Date Issued: September 11, 2019 CHELMSFORD FEDERATION OF TEACHERS, AFT LOCAL 3569 * * MUP-17-6374 Board Members Participating: Marjorie F. Wittner, Chair Katherine G.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD RRKEKEERERERRRERRERREEKKREEERERERERERRRRERERERRREEREERREEE In the Matter of CHELMSFORD * SCHOOL COMMITTEE * Case No. MUP-17-6374 and * Date Issued: September 11, 2019 CHELMSFORD FEDERATION OF TEACHERS, AFT LOCAL 3569 * * Board Members Participating: Marjorie F. Wittner, Chair Katherine G.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS ************************************* In the Matter of * * CHELMSFORD SCHOOL * COMMITTEE * * and * * CHELMSFORD FEDERATION * OF TEACHERS, AFT LOCAL 3569 * * ************************************* Case No.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS RHEKKKIEKAKRRREEERERERKEKAKKKAKKKK KKK KEKE In the Matter of CHELMSFORD COMMITTEE * SCHOOL and * * Case No.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matter of CHELMSFORD SCHOOL COMMITTEE and Case No. CHELMSFORD FEDERATION OF TEACHERS, AFT LOCAL 3569 Hearing Officer: MUP-17-6374 Date Issued: June 29, 2022 Meghan Ventrella, Esq. Appearances: Haidee Morris, Esq. Harold Jones, Esq. Representing the Chelmsford Federation of Teachers, AFT Local 3569 Andrew Waugh, Esq. Felicia S. Vasudevan, Esq.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES Charging Party, and Case No.: SUP-20-7945 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS / SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE/ DIVISION OF BANKS Respondent RESPONDENTS WRITTEN RESPONSE On or about March 23, 2020, the Charging Party, the National Association of Government Employees (NAGE or Union), filed a charge alleging that the Respondent, the Commonwealth

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES Charging Party, and Case No.: SUP-20-7945 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS / SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE/ DIVISION OF BANKS Respondent ANSWER NOW COMES Respondent, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, through the Secretary of Administration and Finance, Division of Banks, and hereby answers the Complaint issued on July 10, 2020 as follows

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES Charging Party, and Case No.: SUP-20-7945 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS / SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE/ DIVISION OF BANKS Respondent ANSWER NOW COMES Respondent, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, through the Secretary of Administration and Finance, Division of Banks, and hereby answers the Complaint issued on July 10, 2020 as follows

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES Charging Party, and Case Nos.: SUP-20-7856 & SUP-20-7945 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS / SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE/ DIVISION OF BANKS Respondent Respondents Post-Hearing Brief I.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS CHARGE OF PROHIBITED PRACTICE M.G.L. c.150E DO NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE Case No. Date Filed SUP-20-7945 03-23-2020 INSTRUCTIONS: Answer all applicable questions. Failing to provide information may result in the dismissal of the charge.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD In the Matter of: COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS/ SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE Case Numbers: SUP-20-7856 SUP-20-7945 Date Issued: May 3, 2023 and NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES CERB Members Participating: Marjorie F. Wittner, Chair Kelly B. Strong, CERB Member Victoria B.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS National Association of Government Employees, Charging Party, and Case Nos.: SUP-20-7856 SUP-20-7945 Commonwealth of Massachusetts/ Secretary of Administration and Finance/ Division of Banks, Respondent I. INTRODUCTION This is a simple case, with largely undisputed facts and law.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF LABOR RELATIONS In the Matter of COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE, DIVISION OF BANKS and Case Nos. SUP-20-7856 and SUP-20-7945 Date Issued: June 29, 2022 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES, LOCAL 207 Hearing Officer: Kendrah Davis, Esq.