Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

Dunlap, 27 MLC 113, 114 n.6, SUPL-2696 (February 9, 2001) (declining to find that drug test violated employees rights under the United States Constitution); Town of West Springfield, 21 MLC 1216, 1222-1223 (August 19, 1994) (citing Plymouth Police Brotherhood v.

See Town of West Springfield, 8 MLC 1041, 1047 (1981) (noting that a union vice presidents ticketing of patrol cars, abusive and threatening conduct and insubordinate refusals to act fell outside of the realm of protected activity.). In the present matter, Bernard acted in an insubordinate fashion when she informed Clerge that she did not want to be told what to do with regard to MAP maintaining MAP recertification.

See Town of West Springfield, 8 MLC 1041, 1047 (1981) (noting that a union vice presidents ticketing of patrol cars, abusive and threatening conduct and insubordinate refusals to act fell outside of the realm of protected activity.). In the present matter, Bernard acted in an insubordinate fashion when she informed Clerge that she did not want to be told what to do with regard to MAP maintaining MAP recertification.