Malakie requested a copy of"the proposed settlement agreement with National Grid regarding gas leaks and damages to [C]ity trees." You denied access to the responsive record in a response dated July 12, 2016. The City's July 12 response In the City's July 12 response to Ms. Malakie you indicate "the Law Department is asserting the attorney-client privilege in connection with the production of the document at this time."

Manner of Settlement in Last Two Contract Negotiations settlement 44, Petition Submitted By: [L]abor Organization [E]mployer [J]ointly L 45. Signature Of Petitioning Party 47. Date 46. Title Attorney 48. Signature of Principal Representative of Other Party if Joint Petition 49. Title 50.

Manner of Settlement in Last Two Contract Negotiations 7 oe _ [Attorney HR | | Police Chief C a | BS | OS oe | | 44. Petition Submitted By: [L]abor Organization [EJmployer [Jointly en 45, Signature Of Petitioning Party 46. Title iL | 47. Date Union Counsel | | | 49. Title 50. Date ! 48.

Feathers requested records pertaining to "[ c]opies of all presentment letters and settlement memorandums regarding settlements that were reached by the city in calendar year 20 17" as well as "[ c]opies of all police department internal affairs investigation reports completed during calendar year 2017." Not having received a response, Mr. Feathers appealed to this office.

Manner of Settlement in Last Two Contract Negotiations Negotiated Settlement | ! 44. Petition Submitted By: [L]abor Organization [E]mployer [J]ointly 45. Signature Of Petitioning Party 46. Title 'L | Counsel | 48. Signature of Principal Representative of Other Party if 49. Title If Petition is brought individually, I hereby state That I have caused a copy of this Petition to be Served on the Principal Representative of the other Party (51.

Description of Any Prohibited Practice Charges Pending Between the Parties None Other Information Size and composition of Units (Total # of Employees Covered by the Contract) 18 sworn officers, 3 dispatchers Name and Titles of Members of Bargaining Committees Union Graham Maxfield, Daniel Keith Dowd Cloutier Jason Martocci Chief Robin Negotiator Management Craver Joe Szafarawic Cynthia Cooper res Pp t SFameSPeFEVteF Manner of Settlement in Last Two

(Cog hokiant) Schoo] 2 Sk RECOMMENDING CLOSURE: Case settled O Referred to voluntary binding arbitration (G.L. c. 150E, 9) | Other: SESSION DATES: : - MANAGEMENT (only) UNION (only) OO ON DO HR Wp OMNORWD w~ LUM Y CONOR WHE a JOINT OTHER COMMENTS: (e.g. additional settlements i.e. ULPs) MEDIATOR: ss a == a * DIRECTOR: CO APPROVED CASE CLOSED SIGNED: i PA : ; QO OTHER: DATE:

D'sk RECOMMENDING CLOSURE: Case settled LJ CI Referred to voluntary binding arbitration G, L. c. 150E, 9) _ Other: SESSION DATES: 4, 6. 7 (eg. additional settlements i.e. ULPs) MEDIATOR: ie SIGNED: - DX OD _ wp OTHER COMMENTS: ] 8 Rh 3 OD 2 UNION (only) ON fill 6 , MANAGEMENT (only) OM NORHON A JOINT Doe on "DATE: DIRECTOR: C1) APPROVED CASE CLOSED SIGNED: C OTHER: DATE: hocking) ) Cf 2afy

Manner of Settlement in Last Two Contract Negotiations Mediation, Negotiated Settlement 44, Petition Submitted By: [L]abor Organization [E]mployer [J]ointly 45, Signature Of Petitioning Party 46. Title 48. Signature of Principal Representative of Other Party if |49. Title IL 47. Date Secretary Treasurer/BA 50.

the Parties MUP-18-6943 reduction in safe apparatus staffing Other Information Size and composition of Units (Total # of Employees Covered by the Contract) ~44 all firefighter ranks below deputy Name and Titles of Members of Bargaining Committees Union Barry Shea, President Sean Cashman, Vice-President Patrick Bryant, Union's Attorney Management James Boudreau, Town Administrator Robert Clark, HR Director John Clifford, Town's Attorney Manner of Settlement

Sunkenberg, James (DLR) From: Sent: James Hykel Wednesday, August 29, 2018 10:26 AM To: Sunkenberg, James (DLR) Ce: Subject: Jack Collins Re: Oak Bluffs, MUP-17-6101, MUP-17-6323, MUP-16-6654 Good morning, Pursuant to the parties' settlement, the Charging Party hereby withdraws the charges in the above-captioned matter. Please let me know if you require anything further.

The parties are directed to bring individuals with settlement authority to the mediation, or have individuals with settlement authority available by telephone that day. Under no circumstances will mediation delay the scheduled expedited hearing date. ARBITRATION: Pursuant to Chapter 151, Section 577 of the Acts of 1996, parties may submit the case to an impartial arbitrator, subject to the requirements set forth in that statute.

lv] Yes LJ No Note: The DLR may decline to issue a complaint unless reasonable settlement efforts have been made by the charging party. 456 CMR 15.04(1). INFORMATION ON CHARGING PARTY 17. Name 18. Representative to contact Oak Bluffs Professional Firefighters & Paramedi| 19. 20. Telephone Number James Hykel 617-367-7200 Address (street and No., city/town, state, and ZIP code) . 21.